Try NFL Sport Channel Seach:
Selected searches:
NFL Football Players Draft Injuries Rookies Season SuperbowlPublished: October 3, 2009
This is a preview of week 4 in the league. There was no research done in this article, just what goes through my mind when I see the matchup on paper.
Quick side note; the numbers on the left of team’s are my power rankings.
Overall: (32-16)
Last Week: (10-6)
(3) Baltimore (3-0) @ (9) New England (2-1) – 1:00/CBS
I am unsure why New England is favored in this one. Baltimore is No. 1 on many power rankings, and people talk about them being the best team. The Ravens are right around where I expected them to be in terms of success on both sides of the ball.
Flacco is proving himself as a reliable player for the offense and McGahee is displaying a great deal of strength, vision and speed.
Another thing I have heard all week is how will Brady pass against the Raven secondary. This game might be won on how well Brady plays, but his offensive line will be the determining factor.
You can’t forget about Suggs, Ngata, Gregg and all the other blitzers Baltimore is capable of unleashing. The Ravens should pressure Brady just as much as New York did, and it will come down to how well the Patriots protect their star.
Both backfields have the potential to breakout any given week, but I don’t see this game won on the ground.
I also hear that Welker might not play. I was convinced in week two that the Patriot offense is too out-of-sync and too vulnerable for Brady to find more success than none when being pressured against a solid defense.
Are you more convinced that Baltimore’s defense can pressure Brady, or that New England’s offense can handle it?
Pick: BAL
(30) Tampa Bay (0-3) @ (24) Washington (1-2) – 1:00/FOX
The crystal clear problem with the Redskins is Clinton Portis not rushing the football. What’d he rush, 14 times last week? This guy should be the main focus of your offense, not Jason Campbell.
Campbell can ball, but he is not the best playmaker on Washington’s offense. Santana showed good signs last week, and he is more than capable of making consistent big plays.
Tampa finally benched Leftwich though, so don’t be surprised if their offense shows signs of explosion in the game. The playmakers around the quarterback position are very under-rated for Tampa. Cadillac and Derrick are both dangerous rushers, and Winslow has been a constant red-zone threat.
I don’t see Washington losing this game at home, mainly because I don’t think their defense will allow Tampa situations to possibly win. A close game at best for the Bucs, and possibly a better offense.
Pick: WAS
(19) Tennessee (0-3) @ (27) Jacksonville (1-2) – 1:00/CBS
Tennessee is the biggest disappointment in the league so far. Good news for Titan fans though, it’s only week four. If Tennessee expects to make comeback in the season, they have to win this divisional game.
The Titans defense has given up too many plays in the past two weeks. Teams are both driving on them and making big plays. This is a perfect ‘gut-check’ game for the Titans. They are playing against a less-than-average offense that is mainly one-dimensional.
Chris Johnson will need to see a majority of the touches on the ground and possibly the air. Jones-Drew is capable of scoring more than once, but Garrard will need to make consistently good decisions to keep this game close or win it.
Pick: TEN
(28) Oakland (1-2) @ (18) Houston (1-2) – 1:00/CBS
I’m expecting a physical game with a handful of big plays. Houston’s defense has struggled tremendously (in my eyes), but the offense might be back on track.
Slaton is slowly but surely coming along, and overall they seem much more focused and mature as an offense opposed to last season.
The Oakland defense can stop Houston’s rushing attack, but the matchup between Asomugha and Johnson will determine how close this game can be.
Russell is not the answer for a successful Oakland offense, but he is the problem. When it comes down to it, Houston’s offense should outscore Oakland’s, no matter how well the Raider defense can play.
The only way I see Oakland winning is if they force Houston’s offense to score with the final possession. But even then, I would place my money on Houston in that situation.
Pick: HOU
(15) Chicago (2-1) @ (26) Detroit (1-2) – 1:00/FOX
If Detroit’s secondary wasn’t so bad, I would probably pick them to win this game. The Lion’s front seven is not great, but they are much more improved as opposed to last season.
The Lion’s can pressure Cutler if the focus is there and plays are made; but Cutler’s throwing skill is too good for the Lions to win the passing battle. Can Detroit keep up with Cutler? Possibly.
Stafford has been playing well, and Calvin Johnson hardly saw the ball in last week’s victory. If Detroit can avoid three-and-out situations and convert on third downs, then we might see some lead changes.
I like the direction Detroit’s offense is heading, but their pass defense is too bad to seriously pick against the Bears.
Pick: CHI
(17) Cincinnati (2-1) @ (32) Cleveland (1-2) – 1:00/CBS
It doesn’t really matter who is quarterbacking for Cleveland. They have an inconsistent running game, they don’t block up front and Braylon Edwards is steadily becoming an unreliable player for the offense.
The defense is still in the middle of a giant riddle and the only thing Anderson will provide is a possible big play down the field every now and then.
He has made the Pro Bowl though, so he has the potential to play well. But there are too many problems around Anderson that even if he plays well, Cincinnati is to good of a team to lose.
I said it at the beginning of the season and I will continue to say that Ochocinco is back as the difference maker of that offense.
He is a consistent threat in one-on-one situations and draws attention off other receivers on the Bengal roster (i.e. Caldwell, Coles).
Cedric Benson has been a very pleasant surprise to me, and the Bengal offense is actually looking like they know how to drive down a field. This could be a snowball effect game for Cincinnati if they win, which I expect them to do… big!
Pick: CIN
(25) Seattle (1-2) @ (2) Indianapolis (3-0) – 1:00/FOX
It is hard to pick against Peyton at home. There is not much to say about this game. The Colts look like an all-around offense again, and the Seahawks (once again) are hurting with injuries.
Jones has surprisingly ran the ball hard so far, and we all know the struggles Indy’s run defense has. It shouldn’t be a determining factor here as Indy has no excuse to loose this game.
Pick: IND
(1) New York Giants (3-0) @ (29) Kansas City (0-3) – 1:00/FOX
This is another easy game to pick with not much to discuss. New York will out rush, throw, kick, blitz and cover Kansas City.
We all know what the Giants’ pass rush is capable of, especially against an offense that is struggling both running and passing.
Eli will more than likely make this defense look worse than they truly are. This might be another blowout similar to what you saw New York lay against Tampa.
Since we’re on Kansas City and I have nothing more to say about this game, let me spitball with them for a minute.
Dwayne Bowe has proven his reliability as a No. 1 target, but that’s all that is right with this offense. Cassel and the rushing game has struggled, which may reflect the offensive line.
Defensively, the Chiefs are better than I expected, but I think their potential is through the roof. They have shown great signs of playing tough, physical defense.
Maturity and a terrible rushing game is holding Kansas City back from being a slightly above-average team. They play well more times than none when you consider the teams they have to play outside their schedule.
Pick: NYG
(8) New York Jets (3-0) @ (10) New Orleans (3-0) – 4:05/CBS
To me, this is the game of the week. These are two teams that not many people saw undefeated heading into week four.
How well Drew Brees handles the Jets’ blitz packages wil determine whether New Orleans can win the game. The Saints have been rushing the ball extremely well, but they are facing one of the toughest defenses they will see all year.
Kris Jenkins might have something to say about New Orleans recent success on the ground, but I have said this once and I will keep saying Pierre Thomas should never be slept on.
If Thomas can produce solidly when his number is called, Brees can take the game from there. New Orleans’ defense is the biggest mystery in this game. They have played well so far this season, but can they play as consistent as the Jets’ defense?
The Saints should disrupt Sanchez for a majority of the game; but if the New York defense can slow the rushing game and beat the protection, they might escape with a victory.
Pick: NYJ
(21) Buffalo (1-2) @ (22) Miami (0-3) – 4:05/CBS
Miami is a better team than their record shows, with Pennington under center. I liked Miami until I heard the news about Pennington’s injury. Miami’s offense is good, but they are not going to score at will.
Marshawn is coming back and (I feel) the only thing that will slow him down is splitting carries with Fred Jackson.
The Miami defense will have to slow a potentially dangerous Buffalo offense to keep this game close.
I expect a lot of three-and-outs from the Dolphin offense, but Ronnie Brown can produce nicely for a whole game.
If Buffalo wants to have a successful season, they need to win this game which will ultimately come down to the offense (like always) which measures down to Trent Edwards (like always).
Buffalo’s offense could produce nicely and still lose, but that would lay on the Bills’ defense which I don’t see happening with Henne as the starter.
Pick: BUF
(14) Dallas (2-1) @ (20) Denver (3-0) – 4:05/CBS
If Denver wins this game, I will be completely sold on their defense. The only way I see Denver winning is if they pressure Tony Romo.
Romo struggles when he is pressured, and it is the easiest formula for victory against Dallas. I am already sold on their secondary; but if their front seven can disrupt Romo enough that Denver pulls this off, then I will be head over heels for them.
Tashard’s performance can go either way, but I don’t think it will become the determining factor in this game. If Romo doesn’t turn the ball over, Dallas wins. If Denver’s defense is 3-0 legitimate, they will give the offense an opportunity to win.
Will the offense follow through? I don’t see Denver’s offense running away with this one, but it seems to be slowly becoming more effective (which could make for a close game).
Pick: DEN
(31) St. Louis (0-3) @ (11) San Francisco (2-1) – 4:15/FOX
Although Gore is not playing, I don’t expect the 49ers to struggle on offense. Coffee is capable of producing solidly, especially if the Niners passing game is as good as I think it is.
I feel Vernon is on the verge of breaking out pretty soon and the defense is as physical and fundamental as they come. I don’t see St. Louis doing any damage on either side of the football.
Boller might actually make more plays than Bulger did, but I don’t see enough to beat San Fran on the road.
The Niners might be stinging from that loss to Minnesota, so they could be very dangerous and determined this week.
Pick: SF
(12) San Diego Chargers (2-1) @ (7) Pittsburgh (1-2) – 8:20/NBC
This should be a great smash-mouth game between two teams with something to prove. Both team’s rushing attack has struggled to say the least; so if Tomlinson can return and run well, it might give the Chargers an edge.
Despite losing last week, I trust Pittsburgh’s defense more times than none. There should be great amount of pressure on Rivers, so if the Pittsburgh secondary can fill into their roles, it should produce a greater chance of victory for the Steelers.
I have been bashing the offensive line for Pittsburgh, but it’s time the receivers stepped up and caught some passes. Back to back weeks, Pittsburgh has had a receiver drop an open pass in the end zone.
Rivers might be able to keep this game close, but I trust the Steelers on all three aspects (kicking, offense, defense) for a full 60 minutes.
Pick: PIT
(16) Green Bay (2-1) @ (5) Minnesota (3-0) – 8:30/ESPN
This should be a fun game to watch. Getting right into it, Adrian Peterson should have a successful evening. I’m interested to see how Favre plays since nobody knows him better than Green Bay.
Minnesota’s defensive line should have no problem pressuring Rodgers and stopping the run. I like both defenses causing turnovers in this one, but the Vikings matchup equally or better with Green Bay on almost very aspect.
This is going to be a great game. My most honest piece of advice in this one is to expect the unexpected.
Pick: MIN
BYE: (4) Atlanta, (6) Philadelphia, (13) Arizona, (23) Carolina
Read more NFL news on BleacherReport.com
Published: September 25, 2009
This is a free-style preview of what Week Three in the league has to offer us as fans. No research was used to write this preview, it is just simply what goes on in my mind when I see the matchups on paper.
Last Week: (10-6) Season: (22-10)
Washington Redskins (1-1) @ Detroit Lions (0-2) – 1:00/FOX
Washington has been a surprising struggle in my mind so far this season. Detroit has improved by adding some skill players here and there, but the defense and offensive line still needs work.
Stafford showed improvement last week, but Detroit still cannot find a consistent rushing attack. Facing the Washington defense with a one-dimensional offense is probably not the best formula for a victory.
If Detroit can consistently attack the Washington defense with Kevin Smith, then I expect the Lions to keep the game within reach. The Detroit defense is nothing to praise though.
Washington squeaked by with three field goals to defeat arguably the league’s worst team. In the league though, a win is a win no matter what. Washington’s offense will probably emphasize the run with Portis, throw a few west coast routes, then take some shots deep (preferably with Santana).
The Lions’ defense is more than capable of getting torched by a majority of NFL offenses, so Kevin Smith will have to run hard in this game to give the Lions a fighting chance. I just don’t see the Detroit defense holding Washington’s offense for an entire 60 minute game, regardless of last week’s performance.
Pick: WAS
Green Bay Packers (1-1) @ St. Louis Rams (0-2) – 1:00/FOX
The Green Bay Packers will not be a playoff contender unless they find an offensive line. Aaron Rodgers is always under constant pressure and Ryan Grant can’t cross the line of scrimmage before being wrapped up.
Good news for Green Bay fans though, the Rams don’t have an offensive line either (although it is improving). Bulger played consistently well in last week’s game, but Jackson still needs to be the main target in the offense.
For the most part, St. Louis is a one-dimensional offense which could mean easy PICKings for the Green Bay secondary. The Packers will have to stop the run though in order to make Bulger pass a majority of the plays. This worries me, mainly because of the amount of yards the Packers gave up to Benson.
If the Packer defense cannot stop Steven Jackson, then St. Louis should find success every now and then throughout the game. Running Jackson might not be enough to keep up with the amount of points Green Bay can score (I say between 24 and 28), but I don’t doubt the defensive plan Spagnuolo has either.
If the Rams can get enough pressure on Rodgers to force turnovers and incomplete passes, then attack with Jackson more times than none, I expect a closer game than what most people anticipate. This game might come down to a field goal or the last score of the game, which would be best case scenario for the Rams.
Overall, if Jackson finds success then Bulger will throw fewer balls making it harder for the Green Bay defense to tally turnovers (which usually results in points for Green Bay). If St. Louis can take away the turnovers the Green Bay defense usually forces, I smell an upset.
Can you believe I had this much to say about a Rams game? Me neither.
Pick: GB
San Francisco 49ers (2-0) @ Minnesota Vikings (2-0) – 1:00/FOX
This is going to be a good game with a fairly simple breakdown. This should be a low-scoring game between two physical, tough, smash-mouth teams.
It is no secret that both teams will look to their tailbacks as the centerpiece of their offense in Sunday’s matchup. Peterson and Gore will both see plenty of touches (assuming Peterson plays despite rumors on his injury), but expect both defenses to be keyed in on their opponents backfield.
Ultimately, Minnesota has more playmakers to win a close and tightly contested game; but I have never doubted what Mike Singletary has done for his team. If San Francisco wins this game, it’s because Singletary has his players playing hard, tough, focused football with as much confidence as any other team in the league.
Otherwise, Peterson should find success more times than none, along with the playmakers around him (on offense and defense). Ryan Longwell has been the savior for Minnesota in the past, and week three might call his number again.
Pick: MIN
Atlanta Falcons (2-0) @ New England Patriots (1-1) – 1:00/FOX
As impressive as Atlanta has been these past two weeks, it is very hard to see an upset here. What is interesting (to me) about this game is that both franchises are built around the same philosophy. That is, get an offensive line to protect your quarterback (usually best player on the field) and everything else will fall into place.
Although I (and probably half the nation) give the rushing edge to Atlanta, I don’t see either rushing game doing much in this one. Both teams are going to need a successful passing attack along with some creativity in this one.
Both quarterbacks are more than capable of picking apart either team’s secondary. It will come down to which quarterback can make consistently accurate throws under pressure.
I expect Tom Brady (of all people) to learn from his mistakes and prepare for a tough home game. No one in Atlanta’s secondary matches up with the talent, potential, and skill Darrelle Revis has either. Randy will see plenty of balls his way, deep and short.
Pick: NE
Tennessee Titans (0-2) @ New York Jets (2-0) – 1:00/CBS
Regardless of what people think of Steve Slaton, I still don’t think the Jets have played a true “run first” offense yet. That’s not saying the Jets defense won’t be able to stop it, just something to consider.
Collins is one of the most accurate quarterbacks when he has protection, so it will be very important for Tennessee’s offensive line to pick up blitz packages from the Jets. This game will be won in the trenches. The team who can protect their quarterback and slow the pass rush will find more success on offense.
This will be another hard-fought, physical matchup between two teams fighting for respect. The key to this game will be both of the offensive line’s ability to protect their quarterback against very disruptive defenses. Best case scenario for both teams is that their O-line does protect their respected quarterbacks, in which case I take Collins to make the right decisions and better reads in a tight game.
If Tennessee does lose this game and still plays solid for a large part, it will be because of how good the Jets defense truly is (which would be top five in my mind).
Pick: TEN
Kansas City Chiefs (0-2) @ Philadelphia Eagles (1-1) – 1:00/CBS
Despite all the rumored injuries Philly is facing heading into week three, the Eagles are a much stronger team than the Chiefs.
Philly’s defense is much too fast for Kansas City to handle, but the Kansas City defense has been playing better than expected so far.
Having Kolb or Garcia under center for Philly won’t make much of a difference. Both quarterbacks are prepared for this game the same way, but the main concern comes from the other skill positions.
Will the fact that DeSean and Westbrook might not play be a determining factor? Probably not for the end result, but it might make a difference on how consistently effective the Philly offense is. The Eagles’ defense should be all over the field, making it difficult for Cassel to make good throws.
This game might be a surprise in the aspect of a low-scoring game, but Philly is one of the best teams in putting up points in other ways besides offense. Unless Jamal Charles breaks out, I don’t see Kansas City’s rushing attack being a factor in this game.
Ultimately, the Chiefs are a one-dimensional offense with a defense that has the potential to keep this game within a ten point spread for a majority of the time. The Philly defense is just too fast, tough and smart to give up as many plays as their own offense is expected to make.
Pick: PHI
New York Giants (2-0) @ Tampa Bay Buccaneers (0-2) – 1:00/FOX
It seems like we are heading into the simple games of the week. The Giants are filled with injuries heading into this game. I believe Aaron Ross, Chris Canty, Kenny Phillips and Justin Tuck are all out with an injury…but that shouldn’t make much of a difference.
Plain and simple, the Giants pass rush is the best in the league and should put tons of pressure on Leftwhich. Senior citizens in a powerized scooter could get to Leftwhich by the time he is halfway in motion to deliver a pass.
As time has proven, it doesn’t matter who is at wide receiver for the Giants. They have an offensive line that can both run and pass block like some of the best in the league and a quarterback who can makes the right throws and decisions in the pocket.
There is not much Tampa Bay can do to win this game, mainly because their offense is incapable of keeping up with a majority of NFL teams. They are now facing the toughest defense they have seen all year and an offense that is almost oblivious to any defense thrown their way.
Pick: NYG
Cleveland Browns (0-2) @ Baltimore Ravens (2-0) – 1:00/CBS
We are definitely right in the middle of Week Three’s weakest matchups. The Ravens are running the football better than ever, and Flacco is slowly but surely turning into a complete quarterback.
The Browns have not impressed on any side of the football and have yet to find a reliable playmaker (other than Cribbs) on the team. This game could be over before it begins, not much to say about this one.
Pick: BAL
Jacksonville Jaguars (0-2) @ Houston Texans (1-1) – 1:00/CBS
Every AFC South matchup usually produces a very good game for football fans to watch. This could be a back-and-forth game with a few lead changes.
Both Houston and Tennessee’s defense surprised me by allowing 60-plus points combined last week. Jacksonville’s offense will more than likely go through Maurice Jones-Drew, both in the rushing and receiving game.
Garrard’s ability to makes plays with his feet and arm will determine how close Jacksonville will be able to keep this game. Andre (3 Stacks) Johnson has the ability to break out on this Jaguars defense (mainly because Rashean Mathis is not the same corner back he was three years ago).
I still don’t expect much from Slaton; but if Jacksonville focuses too much attention on “3 Stacks,” then Slaton could really do some damage.
On a side note, Matt Schaub can ball. I’ve personally witnessed it. I was happy for him but was truly sad when he left Atlanta. This kid has the potential to be great because he has a positive and winning mindset every time he’s on the field.
Pick: HOU
Chicago Bears (1-1) @ Seattle Seahawks (1-1) – 4:05/FOX
Forte needs to produce in order for Chicago to be taken as a serious contender. I am starting to lean towards the idea that Seattle has a weak run defense. This game shouldn’t be determined with Chicago’s running game though.
The Bears’ defense might have a field day if Hasselbeck is out. Wallace behind a less-than-average offensive could produce a few turnovers for Chicago, and their defense is more than capable of assisting points.
Cutler will have to play like the Pro Bowler he is if the Bears want to have any success on offense this season. Seattle’s secondary might be weaker than I anticipated as well. I just have way too many questions concerning how legitimate Seattle is without a healthy Hasselbeck or TJ.
I am not sold on Julius Jones either; so if Chicago’s defense can play up to their fullest ability, then Seattle’s defense might be on the field for a very long time.
Pick: CHI
New Orleans Saints (2-0) @ Buffalo Bills (1-1) – 1:00/FOX
This is the most under-rated game of Week Three (in my mind). New Orleans proved last week that they can go on the road, into a climate their not used to, against a very aggressive defense, and dominate the entire game.
Everyone knows football 101: If you dominate the pass game, it opens up the run (and vise versa). Mike Bell has been rushing the ball extremely well; so although Brees is playing MVP status, New Orleans has been running the ball just as successfully.
Buffalo is a well prepared team though. Their defense is under-rated in many aspects, but Fred Jackson has been lighting up the ground game. Buffalo’s pass rush may disrupt Brees, and have more than enough capability to produce points.
The Bills offense is good, but they can not produce the amount of points New Orleans is capable of unless their defense forces many three-and-outs. I liked Buffalo to win this game on paper, but I just talked myself out of my original pick.
Buffalo doesn’t have the offense to pull away from this game, and Drew Brees will come up more times than none in a close game situation.
Pick: NOR
Pittsburgh Steelers (1-1) @ Cincinnati Bengals (1-1) – 4:15/CBS
Surprisingly, this is the toughest game for me to choose this week.
I know what Cincinnati is capable of when Pittsburgh decides to play down to their opponent’s level. Chad Ochocinco is as dangerous as ever, and he has begun having fun by talking trash.
Polamalu out hurts a lot, but our (meaning Pittsburgh) biggest weakness is the offensive line. Our rushing attack is weaker than ever, and Big Ben has no time in the pocket before he is forced to scramble.
The Bengals defense is more than capable of disrupting Roethlisberger, but I expect the entire Steeler team to be much more mentally focused than they were against Chicago.
Don’t be surprised if the Bengals win; but if the Steelers made a few plays here and there, they would’ve won that football game. Basically, if Cincinnati is able to keep this game close, I expect a much more aggressive and determined Pittsburgh offense driving down the field.
Pick: PIT
Denver Broncos (2-0) @ Oakland Raiders (1-1) – 4:15/CBS
Denver’s defense has been playing well for the most part, but Bush and McFadden (I feel) are a very under-rated running duo. Denver has yet to be tested in the middle of their defense.
I am sold on Denver’s secondary however, and JaMarcus will again be the determining factor on Oakland’s fate.
The Raider defense is good enough to produce points on the board in a hostile environment. If Oakland’s defense can help in some way put points on the board (literally or field position wise), all they need is consistency from McFadden and Bush.
Miller might see many of the few passes Russell completes, but I like Oakland’s defense and rushing attack (especially at home and a divisional game).
Quick shout-out to Richard Seymour who is going hard!
Pick: OAK
Miami Dolphins (0-2) @ San Diego Chargers (1-1) – 4:15/CBS
Phillp Rivers has developed into a reliable quarterback in close situations. I pretty much expect the same outcome of this game as Miami’s Monday night game.
The Dolphins will look to pressure Rivers with Porter and Taylor, compete on offense, but loose in the secondary.
Rivers should have a field day with Gates and Jackson, regardless of how close Miami keeps this game. I expect this game to be closer than the scoreboard will show.
Pick: SD
Indianapolis Colts (2-0) @ Arizona Cardinals (1-1) – 8:20/NBC
Last week’s Monday night went as expected, except the end result. This is another good game with a fairly simple breakdown.
With a weak secondary (due to Sanders’ injury), the Arizona offense should produce an efficient amount of points.
I believe the Colts will feel the same amount of pressure that Miami had, but the Cardinals’ secondary can actually back up their pass rush.
Indy has the ability to rush the ball, but the Cardinals’ front seven are way too athletic and fundamental.
Peyton might be the one turning the ball over in this game, but I still believe Arizona is a top team in the NFC. Despite Peyton playing, Arizona (in my mind) has just way too many weapons on both sides of the football with a coach who will be well prepared.
Pick: ARI
Carolina Panthers (0-2) @ Dallas Cowboys (1-1) – 8:30/ESPN
Marion out of this game will not affect their rushing attack. Jones and Choice are both very capable of producing solid numbers. The Dallas offensive line and secondary are their weakest positions, but the Giants are team that plays well against that lineup.
Carolina will only have success if they can rush the ball, which is one positive that I can point out for Dallas’ defense (their run defense). Carolina’s pass rush shouldn’t affect Romo’s comfort level in the pocket. Romo should be successful for a large part of the game, and the rushing game should produce solidly.
The only way I see Dallas loosing this game is if their secondary continues to give up big plays through the air.
Pick: DAL
Read more NFL news on BleacherReport.com
Published: July 15, 2009
Ranking the best overall defensive tackles the league has to offer.
You know the routine, so let’s get into it.
1. Kevin Williams (MIN)
Can you believe this player was booed by Minnesota fans when he was drafted with the 17th pick?
Williams has incredible power and acceleration that allows him to break off of any block thrown his way. His ability to stop the run, along with his consistent pressure, forces almost every team to double this guy.
If they don’t, then their quarterback is in for a long day. His size deceives his overall ability to attack offenses in so many ways (he has fundamentally perfected the position).
Williams’ success is backed up with playmakers like Pat Williams and Jared Allen, but his overall game has become one of the most impressive in any young player.
I am so impressed with his power, explosiveness, and ability to blow up plays.
His youth combined with his overall football skill is very rare to find in players, and his leadership role has become noticed.
2. Albert Haynesworth (WAS)
Haynesworth is one of the biggest bodied tackles with amazing strength. He can move blockers anywhere he wants and explode into the backfield at will. He seems to come up with big plays at the line of scrimmage, which helps everyone else on defense fall into place nicely.
With that said, he has yet to play an entire season healthy and left a great situation in Tennessee for the moolah. Nothing against Washington, but I believe right now Tennessee is an overall better organization for preparing players to the best of their abilities to win an NFL Championship.
I just feel that Tennessee is a better team for talents to become more mature and focused toward the true success of football. I am not taking anything away from Haynesworth’s game (I have him ranked two!), but I would feel more confident in his level of consistency, reliability, and determination if he still played for Jeff Fisher.
Although the big numbers in Haynesworth’s stats and paycheck might look nice, he needs to prove he can take on a much more serious and reliable role in Washington for an entire season.
His productivity the past two years has been remarkable, but I am just not completely sold on him being much more productive than his time in Tennessee (that doesn’t mean he won’t play well, just not the absolute proven at the position).
3. Kris Jenkins (NYJ)
Jenkins has the best raw strength I have seen. He can move an entire pocket by himself, along with the opponents trying to block him. He is a perfect size and skill for the 3-4 defense, and Ryan should help bring out the absolute best in him (which could elevate his game to a Defensive Player of the Year Award).
His knowledge is some of the best, and he brings a hard hitting, no-stopping aggression to the line. He can get off the ball extremely well, and I wouldn’t argue if you ranked him above Haynesworth or even the No. 1 spot.
4. Casey Hampton (PIT)
Hampton is a small tackle from his height, but a huge one from his weight. Hampton has underrated strength and amazing awareness. He has a nose for sniffing out any running play up the middle and does a good job of setting the outside guys up to make a play.
He can explode through a majority of blockers in the league, and has the speed to destroy a play if he can beat guys with just one move. He has become a reliable player for the Steeler franchise and has been consistently productive.
A hard working, hard playing player with as much talent and skill as any tackle makes Hampton an often overlooked, but effective player.
5. Pat Williams (MIN)
This is the biggest defensive lineman in the league. Williams will literally eat anyone who comes into the gap he is assigned. His strength and knowledge disrupts many offensive plays. He can knock over more than one lineman at a time while trying to make a play toward the ball carrier.
His speed and acceleration are not as strong as his counterpart Kevin, but his power, strength, size, and IQ make him one of the biggest playmakers on the defensive side of the ball.
6. John Henderson (JAC)
To me, Henderson is the scariest tackle today. He busts his head and gets others to hit him in the face to get pumped before games. His strength and pure athletic power make him one of the most dangerous players already.
His attitude and leadership displayed every week put him over the top as one of the absolute best. He is one of the biggest, baddest dudes to play tackle, and has the big play ability that can spark any defense.
In Trillville terms, Henderson is the biggest head bussa in the league.
7. Tommie Harris (CHI)
Harris was arguably the best tackle in the league two to three years ago. Since then, Harris has struggled with injuries, but has not lost a step in his game when he does play.
Again, I think the Cutler deal was bigger than most people realize. The move should bring a higher level of confidence and desire to work harder for everyone on the Bear roster.
I think Harris’ proven talent, and the fact that he has not lost any piece to his game, can make him a top tackle this year. He will need to stay on the field more consistently, but overall, his work ethic and determination to succeed should be higher.
That could bring a more consistently productive season for him and the entire team.
8. Haloti Ngata (BAL)
He has the best power to speed ratio at the position today. His reaction to plays is so quick compared to most tackles today. He is extremely explosive coming out of his stance and can beat blockers in various different ways.
His pursuit skills are some of the best at the position, and he has a drive to get the job done. His knowledge has developed faster than I expected, and has the youth and ability to become a long-term and reliable player for any defense (let alone the Raven’s).
9. Jay Ratliff (DAL)
Ratliff is an underrated player with tons of explosiveness and aggression. He seems to make almost every play in the backfield and never seems bothered by anyone trying to block him.
His determination when executing during a play seems unreal. He has the confidence and mindset to make a play every time he’s on the field, and usually does. Ratliff’s overall skill is still improving, which is scary if you think how effective he was last year.
I thought Ware’s presence was the main reason for Ratliff’s early success, but as the season went on, Ratliff’s level of consistency, productivity, and intelligence improved with his pure talent.
He is setup perfectly to become a top playmaker in the league for years to come.
10. Vince Wilfork (NE)
Wilfork has some of the best one-on-one ability in the game. He has great technique and fundamentals along with very impressive power. He has the right to hold out for a new contract, even though New England is unlikely to give it to him.
Despite contract issues, Wilfork is the type of player who will be focused and ready to play. He has a nose for the football and can fill a gap by filling it himself or moving others.
Wilfork’s overall athletic talent at the position, along with his reliable display of dominance, makes him the perfect player (physically and mentally) for the New England organization and any 3-4 defense.
11. Marcus Stroud (BUF)
Stroud is just as powerful and aggressive as any tackle in the league. His pure power, along with his underrated speed and elusiveness, gives opposing blockers a different style to guard than their used to.
His overall athletic ability is some of the best at the position, and he has proven playmaking capability to be a reliable leader on the Buffalo defense.
12. Darnell Dockett (ARI)
Dockett is one of the more athletic tackles in the game. He has a strong-driven character that brings a higher level of confidence and play from his teammates. Dockett took over extremely well from a leadership stand point.
He came into his own as an overall dominant player toward the end of the season. Although he definitely showed a lot of potential and intensity, his consistency lacked early in the year.
Dockett’s performance toward the end of the year can definitely pick back up in ’09, but he needs to deliver the same style of leadership and reliability through next year if he wants to become a definite proven player at his position.
13. Jamal Williams (SD)
Williams is a reliable veteran who has more on his resume than people realize. His size and consistency to produce solid plays has not gone away. He can still rush through the middle of an offense more times than none, and has the attitude to make others better.
His speed and strength have lacked the past two years, but his overall work ethic and productivity level is still some of the best. His presence and skill still make him a big playmaker, just not as consistent as we were once used to seeing.
14. Shaun Rogers (CLE)
I haven’t figured out if Rogers just doesn’t care about anyone but himself, or if he doesn’t care about anything period. His size and athletic ability make him a threat to many blockers already.
Although his overall talent and big play ability is very active, his work ethic and attitude toward the game seem lack luster at best. He is very lazy more times than none and only seems to play when he wants to.
He has proven he cannot be taken as a serious leader for any defense, but still has the skill set to be a dominant player. Rogers has underachieved for a majority of his career, but that doesn’t come from his athletic talent.
It comes from his care-free attitude toward every aspect of the game. Maybe going to a successful franchise can turn Rogers into a seriously great player, but again, that shouldn’t take away from his pure talent.
15. Sedrick Ellis (NO)
Ellis is one of the underrated tackles with a great character and presence. He is a hard worker who develops consistent plays for the Saints’ d-line. Ellis has become a fundamentally sound player with improving mechanics and power.
His speed is pretty impressive to say the least, and his ability to create turnovers seems overlooked. Ellis is a low-key player for the Saints’ defense in the public’s eye, but a huge piece to their success from time to time.
He is still a young player, which is why I don’t think he can lead a defense right now. He has the players around him to elevate his intelligence and possible reliability in the future.
His maturity (along with many Saint defenders) could use improvement.
16. Ryan Pickett (GB)
Pickett is another underrated player with tons of strength and knowledge. His ability to come off the ball surprises many and his tackling skills are very underrated.
I like Pickett’s understanding of where to be in order to make the best play for his defense. His size makes him an easy target to block on stretch plays, but his overall awareness and power make up for that.
Pickett is a reliable player on the inside game, but his containment and acceleration going lateral is a weakness shown many times.
17. Brodrick Bunkley (PHI)
He has come into his own as one of the strongest tackles. His strength is through the roof, along with his determination to break blocks and make plays. His big play ability comes and goes, but has the power and quickness to change directions and chase down many ball carriers.
His toughness is one of the best and has a head hunting mentality to help him develop into a complete player. I’m not sure he will (because I think he’s played up to his prime for the most part), but he still has a lot of time and talent to prove me wrong.
18. Fred Robbins (NYG)
Robbins’ strength and ability to run over guys scares me a lot. He is the most underrated tackle in the game with the maturity and mechanics to be one of the best. His speed coming off the ball needs work, along with his recovery ability.
Overall, Robbins’ power and size make him solid, but his maturity and reliability make him a consistently productive player in the eyes of coaches more so than fans or the media.
Not a flashy player with speed, but he has the power and mentality you look for in championship players.
19. Amboi Okoye (HOU)
An undersized young talent with a great work ethic and character. His strength may deceive many, and his under-the-radar skill to disrupt backfields makes him an overlooked but dangerous player.
I would like to see Okoye take a bigger role, but he is still developing and perhaps time might be his best friend. Okoye’s overall production has been on schedule if you ask me, but I think he has only a year or two to go before he becomes a consistent playmaker.
20. Brandon Mebane (SEA)
Mebane is the backbone of the Seattle line. He is often overlooked, which gives him an advantage. He is a threat to make sacks anytime he beats a blocker. His awareness and strength make him a consistent player who has become reliable as a role player.
I believe his overall talent and maturity will develop him into one of the more successful players down the road. Right now, he is one of the undervalued role players who can make big plays when needed.
21. Darryl Tapp (SEA)
Tapp is a great pas rusher with underrated abilities to create turnovers. He can force fumbles extremely well, and is always disruptive even when he is not close to the ball. He can penetrate a backfield very fast and wraps up opponents with great mechanics.
I love Tapp’s overall football skill, and it shouldn’t be long before he is taken as a serious household name. Tapp’s strength, quickness, and attitude make me love him. He will need to develop a more consistent style of aggression week in and week out if he wants to produce on a top-notch level, which I think he will.
22. Rocky Bernard (NYG)
His career from an overall stand point has been rocky to say the least. When Bernard plays well, he performs that way the entire season (which I like). Bernard is a very inconsistent player, though, when it comes to staying as reliable as he was the year before.
Seattle fans know better than I do as to why Bernard’s success came and went, but he has the athletic power and skill to become a key role player for the Giant defense. Despite his past, Bernard is more than capable of producing big plays in certain situations for a defense.
The fact that he is now with an organization that will favor his success makes me confident in his ability to improve. I think he will improve the Giant team rather than bring his game back to prime level.
23. Adam Carriker (STL)
His career up to this point has been on schedule in terms of development. His aggression is one of the best, and he has big play capability that comes and goes. Carriker will be entering a season where his fundamentals and overall skill should be close to polished.
He was a former defensive end who transferred to the tackle position, so he might have underrated speed. I just haven’t seen NFL speed in his game.
Overall, he is a reliable player in the making who needs to show more of a presence this year than his prior years. He seems like a Spagnuolo type of player. A hard worker with tons of athletic skill and potential.
I think we will see a more mature and overall developed payer in Carriker this year or next.
24. Tommy Kelly (OAK)
Kelly’s reliability needs to be proven in my mind. He has the size and skill to consistently make big plays. He is surrounded by athleticism in the front seven, and has had every advantage most players would love to have. He has teammates that produce for the most part, a size and talent to dominate, and an organization who has his back as of right now.
Kelly has been dodging bullets and perhaps his past has saved him from being cut by now. He better produce like myself and everyone else knows he is capable of, otherwise I don’t see any reason why Oakland should keep paying him.
25. Glenn Dorsey (KC)
He is still transitioning over to the NFL game. His injuries come to concern to many, but it shouldn’t be his most noticeable weakness. Dorsey seemed out of place and lost more times than none.
His pure power and determination are some of the best, but his overall game was very disappointing to say the least. His fundamentals were not terrible, but weren’t great either.
I like the switch Kansas City is making by going to the 3-4. I think it will take pressure off of Dorsey and allow him to play his type of game: one-on-one, power vs. power.
26. Corneilus Griffin (WAS)
Griffin might be splitting PT with Anthony Montgomery. Griffin is coming toward the end of his career, while the young Montgomery seems to be developing quickly. He is a reliable veteran who knows what to do in certain situations.
He still has the ability to make plays in the backfield form time to time. His speed and skills have progressively disappeared, but his presence and strength are still very much there.
I like Griffin as a tough, blue-collar player that might not see the field as much as he’s used to.
27. Peria Jerry (ATL)
Jerry has some of the best aggressiveness I’ve seen from many colleges players. He will be taking over as a starter, and he has the talent around (despite what many might think) to lead his career and team in the right direction.
He explodes off of the ball extremely quickly and aggressively. He always keeps his feet moving and uses all of his strength (legs, arms, and body) to drive through blocks.
28. Ryan Sims (TB)
In the very few games Sims started in, he dominated. He has the potential to become a reliable playmaker with the consistency of producing on all aspects of the game.
His size and explosiveness combined are hard to find in many players today. His overall game has been overlooked for the most part, but he can make big plays on a consistent level given more PT.
29. Jason Ferguson (MIA)
Here is a big body defender with a much more developed game from an overall stand point. Ferguson’s power and knowledge make him a threat as well as his explosiveness (which many successful tackles seem to have).
Ferguson was an overlooked player on the Miami defense. He was a big part in the Dolphins’ success last year, but needs to prove he can play at that same level of consistency and productivity to sustain a secure role in the long run for this or any ball club.
30. Daimone Lewis (CAR)
An overall solid and proven role player, who can fill into holes nicely and make solid plays from time to time.
31. Terrell Sands (OAK)
One of the bigger tackles in size and power. He needs more PT and experience to become a good player.
His athletic talent and size already give him a pretty nice head start.
32. Anthony Montgomery (WAS)
Another big tackle with tons of size and power. He can eat through the inside of many lines and will make a play in the backfield more times than none.
His PT might be limited due to the arrival of Haynesworth.
33. Jason Jones (TEN)
He will be replacing Haynesworth and produced nicely when giving him a break. He is a hard working player with a determined mindset.
34. Chartric Darby (DET)
He has been a reliable role payer his entire career, but now has the opportunity to start over and re-vamp his style for the better.
35. Jay Alford (NYG)
Alford has some of the best athleticism combined with size. He produces every time he plays, only problem is the amount of PT he gets (seems to be the case for a lot of these lower ranked guys).
36. Gerard Warren (OAK)
Has underachieved in his career more than anything. A good role player at best with little to no more reliability.
I consider him a huge disappointment so far in his career.
37. Jonathan Babineaux (ATL)
He is on the verge of having a breakout year. His knowledge has improved vastly along with his consistency of making key plays.
He just signed a five year deal, so his confidence should be high also.
38. BJ Raji (GB)
I like the talent and potential shown by Raji, but if Green Bay wants a long-term player to help them switch to the 3-4, I think they had better options in free agency and the draft than B.J. Raji.
He would probably have more success slowly filling into a 4-3 defense (which also takes pressure off of him).
39. Chris Hovan (TB)
Another reliable playmaker that understands the game inside and out. His overall talent has faded, but his work ethic and capability still can be used to the benefit for some ball clubs (but not many).
40. Travis Williams HOU
41. Barry Coefield NYG
42. Dewayne Robertson DEN
43. Alan Branch ARI
44. Tank Johnson CIN
45. Evander Hood PIT
Published: July 13, 2009
A ranking of the best overall outside linebackers in the league.
1. Shawne Merriman (SD)
Merriman is another serious candidate for the Defensive Player of the Year Award. He is the best fundamental backer with the most football talent. His size gives him strength to move almost anyone trying to block him, but his agility also allows him to spin or run around them.
He will create big plays every time he is on the field and is the type of player that can control your entire defense for the better. He has MVP quality talent that can carry many defenses, and hopefully his injury won’t be a concern this season.
2. James Harrison (PIT)
Harrison’s style to his game reminds me of a cannonball. He is fast, explosive, nasty, and hard hitting. Every time this man blitzes, he creates a big play. Harrison always seems to be in the opponent’s backfield and has the ability to force a turnover every time.
He can force fumbles any time he hits a ball carrier, and is a hard working player who has proven his reliability with a Super Bowl ring and a Defensive Player of the Year Award.
3. DeMarcus Ware (DAL)
Ware has the perfect combination of size and athleticism. He is a 6’4″ freak with ridiculous speed, determination, and awareness. He can reach up high to deflect many passes or just get in between a quarterback’s path to his receiver.
Ware’s blitzing skills are as good as they come, and he has the potential to win a Defensive Player of the Year Award. His ability to get into most backfields quickly, along with his size and athletic talent, make Ware a threat every time he is on the field.
4. Lance Briggs (CHI)
Briggs is one of the most complete backers in the league. He can come up to stop the run, cover most receivers and backs one-on-one, and can make huge plays on a consistent basis.
His tackling skills are remarkable along with his ability to get to ball carriers quickly. He can read plays extremely well and does a good job of executing his role every play. His leadership qualities are some of the best, and he can help keep the Bears’ defense on top of the league throughout the season.
Although Briggs is considered one of the best outside backers today, I believe he is underrated from what a majority of people honestly think of his skill quality. He has MVP talent and capability, but his numbers usually never reflect that.
5. Kieth Bullock (TEN)
Bullock, to me, is one of scariest backers in the game. He brings a big body presence, great leadership skills, vast knowledge of the game, and speed that makes him dangerous on every short yardage play.
His blitzing game is underrated, but effective. He fills holes extremely well, whether it is to make a tackle or just get in the way. His coverage game is par for the most part.
He is a reliable player who brings a high level of intensity and emotion each week.
6. Joey Porter (MIA)
Porter has some of the best leadership skills today. His blitzing skills have been solid for years along with his intensity of play. He will knock anyone out and let them know about it after the play.
He can get to a quarterback very quickly and force a turnover if given the chance. Blitzing with a returning Jason Taylor should only elevate his overall game this season, which is scary if you recall his success without Taylor last year.
7. Terrell Suggs (BAL)
Suggs is a linebacker who creates big plays with his ability to blitz. His speed is some of the best along with his tough attitude and determination. His fundamentals, although previously sloppy, have developed nicely in his game.
Suggs can get beat on some coverages, but his overall skill level and developed mechanics makes him a dangerous (but overlooked) weapon on the Ravens’ defense.
8. LaMarr Woodley (PIT)
Woodley’s style of play is perfect for the Steeler defense. He is a fast and explosive player who comes off the edge faster than most people realize. He has some of the best tackling mechanics at such a young age.
Woodley’s ability to record sacks on a consistent basis makes him a dominant player. So much focus is on Harrison that sometimes teams forget about Woodley, which is a big mistake. His athletic play and quick maturity as a great role player make Woodley one of the most dangerous, but often forgotten, players in the 3-4 set.
9. AJ Hawk (GB)
Hawk is a head hunter for the football. He explodes quickly out of his stance and pursuits almost immediately. He has great tackling skills along with a lot of toughness.
Hawk’s best quality is his tackling ability, but he can also force ball carriers to panic and hit the wrong hole. His strength to shed off of most NFL blocks can use some work, but overall he is a reliable player to make a stop if the play develops in front of him.
10. Ernie Sims (DET)
Sims has some of the most pure athletic talent at the outside backer position. He has the ability to find the ball carriers quickly and can make a big play for his team. Sims’ awareness prevents me from ranking him higher than 10.
It seems Sims is out of position more times than none, and still needs to work on wrapping up opponents that are running down field on him. Although Sims is one of the most athletic backers today, his overall awareness has not seemed to progress in his career.
I do believe the presence of Peterson and Foote will help Sims develop into a smarter player, which will not only help himself out, but his teammates as well.
11. Thomas Howard (OAK)
When people think of the fastest outside backers, Thomas Howard doesn’t come to many people’s mind, but he should. Howard’s outside rushing ability is so quick and precise that it is hard for many running backs to read and pick up.
His big body allows him to eat up space, and his footwork is quick enough to prevent most backs from running around him. Howard’s coverage skills are not bad, but his ability to cover backs running deep routes (like wheels) might hurt him.
His underneath skills (like most backers) are the strong point in his coverage game. Overall, Howard is one of the best rushing backers with more decent coverage skills than people realize.
12. DJ Williams (DEN)
Apparently DJ Williams is moving back to inside backer. Williams is one of the smarter linebackers with enough speed and aggression to make big plays for any defense. He has played both the outside and inside position, so his reliability as a player shouldn’t be questioned.
His athletic talent seems to be what makes everyone love Williams, but his fundamental skills along with his leadership has improved every year he plays with Denver. He is a player who will go hard every play with a confident mindset to be one of the better players on the field.
Williams has slowly (but surely) earned the right to be called a top play maker at the linebacker position.
13. Adailus Thomas (NE)
Thomas has some of the best size in the game today. He is a big body back with the ability to react quickly and make smart plays on the ball. His ability to create turnovers is not as it once was in Baltimore, but he can still rush the outside and fill into gaps extremely well.
His hitting impact is very underrated and rarely misses tackles if he positions himself nicely (which he usually does). His containment is a slight weakness and can get beat if backs can get around him.
To sum it up, Thomas has an inside backer’s body with the skills and ability of the outside position.
14. Chad Greenway (MIN)
One of the more underrated backers, Greenway brings a fundamental and tough presence to the field. His tackling mechanics are very impressive along with his containment skills. He rarely lets ball carriers get by him and does a good job of covering many backs and tight ends.
His speed and overall toughness may surprise many, but Greenway is a blue-collar player who will get the job done regardless. His blitzing game is also underrated, and his overall awareness has become some of the best I’ve seen in young linebackers today.
15. Daryl Smith (JAC)
Smith is a fundamentally sound player who makes the tackles he is supposed to make. He rarely makes mistakes in his assignments and leads the Jacksonville defense by the way he plays.
He is not afraid to hit any player on the field and usually reads plays well. His overall explosiveness is not the best, and his speed lacked last season. He seemed to be a more reliable playmaker in the past, but can still make the reliable plays that make a defensive coordinator’s job easier.
16. Thomas Davis (CAR)
Davis has the speed to beat almost any lineman in the league. He can rush off the edge as well as cover many backs and tight ends. He used to play safety, so his overall coverage skills come with experience and knowledge. His hitting has never been under looked, and he brings as much intensity to the field as his partner Beason.
By now, Davis should have an inside and out understanding of the outside position and his role for that Carolina defense. Davis is an under-the-radar playmaker who can cause trouble for offenses with his speed, hitting skills, and coverage ability.
I would like to see more turnovers caused by Thomas, but he is still one of the most effective players regardless.
17. Clint Session (IND)
He really came into his own last season. Session runs down hill every play like a missile when running into the back field. He is one of the more underrated blitzers in the league, and has the ability to come up and stop any running situation.
His awareness was impressive for the most part last year, but he still needs to work on becoming a more consistent player in clutch situations. His heart and overall attitude toward the game is one of the best, and his mentality to only make his team succeed can make Session a consistently productive player down the road.
18. Julian Peterson (DET)
Peterson is a reliable veteran backer who can make players like Ernie Sims and Louis Delmas better just by his presence. His play recognition, awareness, and toughness make him a solid playmaker for any line backing core.
Peterson is not as dominant as he was in the past, but overall he can still produce not necessarily the numbers, but the progression of the talent around him. He should be one of the leaders of that defense and play with an attitude and determination to teach the youth surrounding him.
His tackling, awareness, and football skills already make him a dangerous player, but now he has the chance to use his experience and leadership skills to develop those around him. Peterson’s presence (in essence) could make the Detroit defense better, but he will have to play hard, aggressive, and productive, which I think he still can.
19. Derrick Johnson (KC)
Johnson has been a mystery to me ever since joining the league. His athletic talent is some of the best, but his consistency as a reliable playmaker comes and goes almost every week.
I have witnessed Johnson makes great plays on the balls which have led to turnovers and broken plays. I have also witnessed Johnson get pulled seven or eight yards down a field by Michael Turner. His overall football skills are some of the best developed, but Johnson doesn’t seem to have the confidence of a great player throughout the entire season.
Johnson seems to play out of sync in the middle of season as if his game was stuck in the twilight zone. He had better step up and play to his full potential on a consistent basis, but other than that, Johnson’s athleticism and football skill can make him a top player for years to come.
20. David Thornton (TEN)
Thornton is one of the toughest, smartest, and most reliable backers in the league. He is another big body backer who can read plays extremely well and blow them up quickly.
His turnover capability is often overlooked and sets up others well to make great plays. His tackling skills are very impressive, but he lacks in the coverage game. He will make big plays when given the opportunity, and rarely misses his assignments.
An all around solid player any franchise can be successful with because of his pure football talent throughout his entire game.
21. Calvin Pace (NYJ)
Since I don’t use notes or other resources when writing these rankings, I can’t remember how many games Pace is suspended for (someone help me out). Regardless, he has some of the best size and speed that allows him to power over or get by many blockers in his path.
His coverage skills are weak because his size and build is much greater than his actual speed. Pace is a game changing player who can create big plays when you least expect it. He is another player who does what is asked of him by being fundamentally sound and mentally focused.
Whenever Pace comes back, he will be just as effective as he was last season.
22. Shaun Phillips (SD)
Phillips is an overall underrated backer that can blitz as well as any other in the league. His overall awareness, when it comes to attacking specific holes, is very impressive. His hitting surprises me more than anything, mainly because he has an unorthodox style of bringing down ball carriers.
His turnover capability is still one of the best and will probably increase with a returning Merriman. I’m not sure what Phillips’ future holds (mainly because they drafted Larry English), but he is an athletic player with big play ability in any given situation.
23. Larry English (SD)
He is a straight up beast. He runs through blocks like it is his job. He will be converting from the defensive end position to outside backer, but should have little to no effect on his overall game.
His legs never stop moving, and he has a knack for coming at quarterbacks from the perfect angle. He can run down many players who try to run east-to-west and should not be overlooked as a key playmaker for certain situations.
His numbers might not reflect his overall ability and success in the future because of the PT he will have to share.
24. Cato June (HOU)
June is a proven linebacker with veteran instincts. He can still make solid plays for a defense and has some of the quickest reaction skills. His blitzing skills are not the strongest, but he is fast enough to make plays on the run or cover most players.
His overall coverage skills are greater than his hitting, but the knowledge and consistency June has displayed for the majority of his career might turn the Texans’ young line backing core into a group of young and mature playmakers.
25. Curtis Lofton (ATL)
Lofton was very impressive for his rookie year in the league. I am not sure if Atlanta will move Peterson to outside or Lofton (because Lofton was inside last year), but his football talent may be used to a higher standard if he plays the outside position.
Lofton was so quick at running to the ball from the inside position. He made tackles from many angles of the field and brings an overlooked toughness to his game. He is a very mature player for his youth and delivered a confident and impressive game last season.
The only thing I see slowing Lofton down from being a top linebacker is injuries, but his consistent playing time shown last year makes me think high of what he and the linebackers playing with him can contribute this year.
26. Aaron Curry (SEA)
Curry was the most impressive defensive player I saw in the draft last year. He has great quickness when changing direction and his strength is some of the best. His awareness and reliability needs to be proven (because he is a rookie), but if he brings the talent he displayed during his time at Wake Forest and at the combine, he is already on the path to becoming a solid player at the absolute worst.
Curry’s size is also overlooked, but a huge piece to his success. I think Curry has the correct mindset and character to learn the NFL game and develop into his own as a great player in the future.
27. Marcus Washington (WAS)
Washington is still a reliable player in the game, but has slowly declined in his pure athletic ability. He is not as fast or explosive as he once was, but can still produce nicely as a key role player for the Redskin defense.
His tackling skills are still impressive and his awareness to be around big plays comes as no mistake. His nasty attitude and aggressive style gives him confidence to produce, which he can, just not as consistently reliable as he used to be.
28. Danny Clark (NYG)
Clark is an underrated backer when it comes to big play capabilities. Clark does a good job of looking to create turnovers. He positions himself nicely to make a good play on the ball carrier and has the quickness physically and mentally to make smart decisions.
Clark’s overall game is more effective in short yardage plays rather than plays that require him to produce while pursuing.
29. Manny Lawson (SF)
Manny’s size and speed is very rare to find in most players today. He is explosive, fast, determined, aggressive, and powerful. The only thing lacking from Lawson’s game is his intelligence.
Lawson should fill into his own this year, because he has some of the best overall athletic talent many linebackers would love to have. I think Singletary will do a good job of using Lawson to the fullest of his potential.
We could see a more confident and mean Manny Lawson this year, which could make him one of the most overlooked playmakers entering the ’09 season.
30. Morlon Greenwood (HOU)
A reliable playmaker who has the size and speed to fill in as a great role player for many defenses. His explosiveness and all around hitting ability is often overlooked, and his knowledge at the position is some of the best.
His fundamentals come and go along with his blitzing game. Greenwood will make the tackle needed, but only if he is in position to. Greenwood has trouble being an effective player when he has to start reacting on a broken play, but for the most part comes up as a reliability more than anything.
31. Kamerion Wimbley (CLE)
His pure athletic talent should go without saying. Wimbley’s athleticism makes me think so highly off him, but he has yet to perform to the fullest of his potential. He often misses many tackles in the backfield and needs to do a better job with his mechanics.
He is out of position more times than none, but does deliver a burst of elusiveness when rushing from the outside. Wimbley over-pursuits a lot, but it’s not like that isn’t fixable.
I would also rather see a player over-pursuit than straight up get beat or ran over. Overall, Wimbley’s play up to this point has been a disappointment, but his athletic talent and rare highlights give me hope that he can develop nicely.
32. Scott Fujita (NO)
Other than his leadership ability, I don’t see Fujita as a serious threat to defenses. Vilma has pretty much taken over the leadership role on both the line backing core and defense.
Fujita is one of the hardest working players with an unselfish mindset. For the most part, Fujita is in position to make plays needed, but only comes up with the play about half of the time.
He doesn’t miss many tackles, but he is an easy player to block out of a running play. Unless Fujita is in position to make a ball on play (he doesn’t have to run across the line or field to make a play), his overall presence on the field shouldn’t be overlooked or taken seriously either.
33. Donnie Edwards (KC)
Edwards has no excuse to produce this year. If he wants to prove he was more than a two or three year player, he needs to play well with players like Thomas, Johnson, Dorsey, and Page.
Edwards has enough talent around him to help lead a defense into the right path. His awareness seems to get worse each season, but his tackling skills are still some of the best.
I also have not seen the same desire or aggression from Edwards that I saw in San Diego. Overall, his big play capabilities have passed along with his consistency to be a reliable and productive player.
He still has the skill in him and around him to become successful, but I just don’t see any motivation for Edwards to play hard this year.
34. Kawika Mitchell (BUF)
Mitchell’s best asset is also his most overlooked. He is an aggressive playmaker who will take risks on plays, but usually pay off. His blitzing skills are some of the best along with his overall attitude when on the field.
Nothing seems to throw this man out of rhythm when he is playing and shows a great amount of determination when running to make a play. I like Mitchell’s overall skill combined with his winning and aggressive attitude.
35. Brian Orkapo (WAS)
He is in the best position to win Defensive Rookie of the Year, but I don’t think he will. Orkapo is arguably coming into the best situation than any other defensive rookie. He will be coming in as the starting backer.
His athletic talent and size make him dangerous, but the talent that surrounds him will only help educate and elevate his game to a higher standard. The only thing holding Orkapo from becoming a household name is Orkapo.
He is setup to have as successful a season as any other rookie on the defensive side of the ball, but it will be up to him to make the most of it.
36. Omar Gaither (PHI)
Gaither is a surprisingly tough and reliable backer with the quickness to get to holes before ball carriers. Consistently, he still has work to do. Gaither’s overall big play ability is hard to find, but his reliability to make the little plays that make defenses successful is very visible.
He is not afraid to run in like a bat out of hell, but also knows when he needs to square up and become fundamentally sound. He brings two different styles to his game, but needs to become just a little bit more consistent if he wants to become and sustain a serious playmaking role for the Eagle defense.
37. Angelo Crowell (TB)
I guess this is a high ranking for Crowell, but only because of the situation he is in. Crowell has the opportunity to develop his game in Tampa. This is a fresh start for a once reliable player to raise his game to an elite status.
Crowell has the talent and work ethic to become one of the best, but as much as I love his game, he still needs to prove it with a new team. His intensity and quickness were always overlooked along with his overall knowledge.
I love Crowell as a big time playmaker, but his dominance has been more absent than present.
38. Vernon Gholston (NYJ)
I am still waiting for Gholston to be used to his best talent. He has the perfect combination of size and speed that will cause problems for any offense. He can blitz using both his power and speed, giving him multiple ways to attack an offense.
What impresses me most about Gholston is his ability to play more than one position (like most 3-4 linebackers). Gholston has equally the same amount of talent at the linebacker position as he does at the defensive end position.
His overall athletic ability and size is what many NFL teams want in their outside backers, but Gholston needs to finally do something with that talent. Ryan might be the guy that can use Gholston to his fullest potential, which could mean opponents have another problem to avoid when facing the Jets’ defense.
39. Kieth Rivers (CIN)
Rivers actually had a pretty decent season, up until Hines Ward cleaned his clock. That injury set Rivers back last season, but he can now use that lost time as motivation and drive to succeed this year. His athletic talent is very impressive.
He has the quickness and speed to catch any ball carrier trying to run to the outside, and the toughness to develop as a reliable inside defender. His awareness needs to improve (obviously after the hit Hines delivered), but seems setup to bring success to himself and the Bengal defense in the long run.
His lack of intensity surprised me as well, but overall was productive until his broken jaw.
40. Freddy Keiaho (IND)
His tackling is as consistent as they come, but he is not going to make the big play that defenses need in certain situations.
41. Clay Matthews (GB)
He is coming into a nice situation in Green bay and has the talent and opportunity to develop into one of the league’s best.
42. Greg Ellis (KC)
He is still sour about the Dallas situation, so he might play with a purpose and chip on his shoulders.
Kansas City is a place where he can do that and produce.
43. Leroy Hill (SEA)
A very underrated and aggressive backer who has great hitting skills along with blitzing.
A low-key player who makes big plays from time to time.
44. Ben Leber (MIN)
A great role player who runs with a motor and never gives up on a play. A fundamental tackler who understands what to do in certain situations.
45. Jamie Winborn (DEN)
Winborn really impressed me last year with his leadership potential and pure aggression.
He hit holes hard and made a lot of tackles.
46. DeMorrio Williams (KC)
His athletic talent is very nice, but his football skill has yet to improve in his time spent in the league.
He will make a nice play from time to time, but his better days were spent in Atlanta (if you can call it better days).
47. Scott Shanle (NO)
Another underrated role player who does a good job of containment and breaking down on tackles.
His speed lacks compared to many outside backers.
48. Brian Cushing (HOU)
Has the ability to win Defensive Rookie of the Year and the attitude to help Houston’s defense strive in the right direction.
A hard working player with a tough mindset is exactly the type of player Houston’s defense was missing to just becoming one of the best.
49. Mike Vrabel (NE)
A reliable veteran player who is also used on offense. Seems like the perfect utility player to Belichick.
Still a great tackler with reliable playmaking skills that make him a very clutch player.
50. Clint Ingram (JAC)
A very athletic linebacker with a lot more heart than brains. He has the potential to become a solid player given the right system and ability to grow in maturity.
51. Chike Okeafor (ARI)
52. Parys Haralson (SF)
53. Stephen Nicholas (ATL)
54. Boss Bailey (DEN)
55. Justin Durant (JAC)
56. Na’il Diggs (CAR)
57. Keith Ellison (BUF)
58. Keith Brooking (DAL)
59. Rocky McIntosh (WAS)
60. Gerris Wilkerson (NYG)
Published: July 12, 2009
Ranking the league’s overall best inside linebackers entering the 09′ season
1. Patrick Willis (SF)
Willis has every characteristic of a great football player. He has a big build to his body with the perfect amount of speed. His awareness and overall knowledge developed quickly along with his leadership skills. Willis explodes into holes faster than any other linebacker and rarely misses tackles. His power and strength combined with his athletic skills make him one of the toughest backers to block. Willis led the league in tackles his rookie season and finished second last year. He is a young talent who has already proven his dominance and reliability as a top player in the league today.
2. Ray Lewis (BAL)
Lewis is still one of the most feared linebackers in the game today. His aggression and emotion should go unquestioned, and his all around talent is close to perfect. Lewis is one of the best pursuit tacklers and can sniff out any play. His leadership in the Raven clubhouse separates himself from many other linebackers today with equal talent. He makes everyone around him better and brings confidence to any teammate sharing the field with him. He reacts to plays better than most backers and will never give up on a play. This is a hard working, proven player that brings confidence and emotion to his game. Combine all of that with his pure ability and you’ll find that Lewis is still one of the best overall players in the game.
3. DeMeco Ryans (HOU)
I always thought Ryans was a steal when Houston drafted him in the second round. Ryans is a tough player who brings a bruiser attitude on the field. His tackling skills are amazing along with ability to hit holes hard. Ryans can take on most fullbacks and does a good job of exploding through blocks. He is a player who can change the entire direction of an offense’s running play and has the ability to create many turnovers (through picks or fumbles). Another young, athletic talent who has proven his dominance in a short time period.
4. Brain Urlacher (CHI)
Urlacher is still one of the smartest and most complete backers today. Urlacher’s toughness has not faded, nor his capability of taking over an entire defense. His ability to read plays is one of the best and has the strength to run over most ball carriers. His toughness and leadership makes him one of the best, but his coverage skills could still improve. Overall, Urlacher is another solid player who you can trust to make the big play for your defense. Now that Cutler is in Chicago, the whole Bear team might have a different attitude throughout the season. Chicago’s defense was already one of the best, and I think it is up to Urlacher to elevate them to a higher standard this season.
5. D’Qwell Jackson (CLE)
He is another young talent with a bright future. His hitting skills are some of the best which has been proven by recording the most tackles last year. His intensity is ridiculous along with his awareness and play recognition. His speed, both physically and mentally, combine to make him a dangerous player from any part of the field. His athletic talent should go unquestioned along with his reliability and big play capability. Jackson’s success shouldn’t be viewed as a fluke because of his pure athletic talent and consistent mature play.
6. London Fletcher (WAS)
Fletcher is an underrated backer who has some of the best fundamental skills at that position. Fletcher does a good job of filling holes and makes the little plays that help defenses. His tackling skills are impressive and his ability to quickly shift the momentum of an offense is rare to find. Fletcher is a deceiving player with a lot of talent and knowledge. He has playoff experience in his career and can help lead any defense with talent (let alone Washington’s) deep into a NFL season. A hard working player with tons of talent, knowledge and maturity makes Fletcher a threat to many teams who like to run inside.
7. Antonio Pierce (NYG)
Another reliable veteran with some of the best leadership qualities. Pierce is another fundamental player who brings a hard hitting style to his game. He fills holes nicely and hardly lets ball carriers break into the secondary. His pursuit skills are not as strong as some other backers, but his awareness and mechanics still make him a dangerous talent. Pierce’s strength is underrated as well as his athletic talent. Pierce is a sound player with tons of fire power and leadership that brings a high level of confidence to his game (along with the best defensive line in the league).
8. Jon Beason (CAR)
Beason had an argument to make the Pro Bowl over Fletcher. He has ranked third in tackles the past two seasons, which were also his only two seasons in his career. There seems to be a bunch of young backers who have proven their dominance early and Beason is another one. His combination of speed and power make him a dangerous threat to any offense. He is a tough down field runner with a hit-first,think-second mindset. His aggression and ability at such a young age will make Beason a reliable player to have for a very long time. His athletic talent and skills will allow him to become a serious leader for a championship ball club, just not this year. This is another player I believe has impressed so well, but hasn’t hit his prime (which is scary to think about).
9. EJ Henderson (MIN)
He could be the most underrated linebacker today. Henderson is a quick and elusive backer with tons of power and strength. He has quickly taken over as a leader on the Minnesota defense, which is impressive to me. He has some of the hardest hitting skills I’ve seen in the game and runs through ball carriers extremely well. His ability to make make his presence felt in the backfield makes him an under-estimated, but dangerous player for opposing offenses. Henderson is a player who can make the entire core better just by his determination and skill to be everywhere the ball is on every play (along with his kick-ass attitude after every hit he delivers).
10. Lofa Tatupu (SEA)
A lot of people forget about Tatupu when it comes to ranking the best inside backers. Tatupu is a proven superstar with play making ability many inside backers don’t hold. Injuries seemed to be his problem last year (along with every Seattle player). He has some of the best skills at reading a quarterbacks eyes and making a play on the ball (which many backers don’t have). He can pick off a ball as well as he can make a tackle. He is always looking to make the big play for a defense, but also understands when he just needs to do his job. Tatupu is a smart player who has proven he has the skill to help a defense succeed deep in a season. His mental toughness makes him a winner already, but his ability to make plays on the ball gives him an advantage over the offense lining up on the opposite side of the field.
11. Karlos Dansby (ARI)
He is another underrated back with tons of athletic talent. Dansby has a skill for reacting quickly on plays and exploding to the football. His speed lacks from his actual explosiveness, but his ability to wrap up and hit is solid. Dansby can make big plays from time to time, but does a better job setting up the players around him. Dansby has the skill to quietly sneak in for a sack, but has a motor that never turns off. He is always looking to strip the ball before actually bringing ball carriers to the ground. Dansby’s all around quickness and play making awareness is often over-looked. He is a pretty solid, but at times risky, backer who can set up and execute big plays for your defense.
12. Bart Scott (NYJ)
Scott’s fun attitude and leadership qualities have really surprised me more than anything. His tacking skills are some of the best along with his ability to read plays and react. He is explosive in his hitting and has a determination when making plays. Scott’s success comes from being a hard working player with a lot of skill. He is one of the more “coachable” players in the league and plays with a level of intensity that may surprise you (a player who lets his play do the talking). His success was proven in Baltimore and he is running the same scheme in New York (along with the same coach).
13. Jonathan Vilma (NO)
Vilma has the ability to completely take over and lead any defense far into a post-season. His fundamentals and mechanics are just as good as his pure athletic talent. He reads plays extremely well and does a good job of wrapping up and bringing down ball carriers. He is a tough defender to get by for most ball carriers and can create or set up big plays at any time during a game. I think he can be more productive than he was last year, but needs more support around him to become a great player on a consistent basis.
14. Barrett Ruud (TB)
Ruud is one of the best fundamental hitters in the game. Ruud’s best qualities include wrapping up and not letting ball carriers get by him. His overall quickness and explosiveness to get to a hole can improve, but his ability to rarely miss tackles makes him as reliable as they come. He is a tough player with a great work ethic. I am not doubting Ruud’s ability to control a franchises’ line backing core; but he didn’t show any leadership signs last year. His statistics don’t lie and he is still one of the most motivated defensive players in the league. I like Ruud as a reliable backer for many teams but if you rely on him to be your game changing presence, you are sadly mistaken.
15. Bradie James (DAL)
James has just as much skill to run over ball carriers as he does to create turnovers. He is arguably one of the best big play linebackers. He can put his head down to make a big stop on the ground. He has the athletic talent and correct mindset to set up big plays and turnovers for the Cowboy defense. He is another player who can feed off of the success of players around him (Ware, Ratliff, etc.), but is a reliable player to give defenses a smart, play making presence at the middle linebacker position.
16. James Farrior (PIT)
Farrior is a tough linebacker with amazing awareness skills. He seems to know what offenses are running and always positions himself to make ball carriers go where ever he wants them to go. His ability to fill a hole quickly also benefits the talent that surrounds him. Farrior has underrated leadership skills and has an overlooked intensity many people don’t realize. His physical toughness measures equally to his mental toughness, allowing him to become one of the more intelligent and clutch players on the field. He is one of the most experienced players from a fundamental and accomplished stand point who has been overlooked the majority of his career.
17. Jerod Mayo (NE)
Mayo’s impact last year was well noticed, but I thought it could’ve been better. He was a rookie last year, so his overall football game should be brought to a higher level entering the 09′ season. Mayo will be entering this season in a more comfortable atmosphere as opposed to last season. Skill wise, Mayo is a fast and strong backer who has a nose for the football. His elusiveness and pursuit skills really impressed me along with his hitting strength. Mayo’s presence in the backfield could be felt more often, but his overall football talent will make him a household name in time to come.
18. Kirk Morrison (OAK)
Another underrated backer with some of the best pure athleticism today. He accumulated the fifth most tackles last year and has very dangerous speed in his arsenal. His hitting skills are underrated (from a power stand point) and his explosiveness to make plays behind the line seems like a habit. Morrison does over pursuit on plays many times, but overall he makes plays more than he gives them up. Recording the fifth most tackles in the league is no easy task, but to ask him to do it on a consistent level for his entire career needs to be proven in my opinion. I think he has the potential to do it however, but he needs to become a bigger leader with a much more aggressive mindset if he wants to secure himself as a long-term starter with Oakland.
19. Mike Peterson (ATL)
Peterson is due to have one of his best seasons he has had in his career. Peterson is a straight athlete with a high level of intensity and insanity. He is fast enough and explosive enough to stop many plays before they cross the line. He has been a proven leader everywhere he has gone and Atlanta should be no different. He will be taking over a group of young linebackers (including one that played well last season). His role in Atlanta’s defense will be crucial, but he can fill the boots. When Peterson plays a full season, he puts up Pro Bowl numbers. His most successful season up to this point in his career was the time he spent in Jacksonville. He recorded over 350 tackles in three full seasons with the Jaguars (seasons he played 16 games). His defensive coordinator at the time was Mike Smith, who is now the head coach for Atlanta. His overall ability and reliability has already been proven, but he had big problems with Del Rio in Jacksonville. Now that he is re-united with his former defensive coordinator, expect the same capable Peterson with a hard working mindset to lead a young team far.
20. Dhani Jones (CIN)
Dhani can make almost any tackle on the field. His ability to get to the ball carrier quickly needs improvement; but from an overall stand point, Jones is arguably one of the best pure tacklers in the game. He knows when to wrap up players as opposed to just knock them out and force a turnover. Jones is one of the most precise backers in the game and has an overlooked toughness in his mental game. He makes big plays more with his tackling rather than his coverage. Overall, Jones’ presence delivers a reliable and fundamental player with a lot more football skill than most people give him credit.
21. Will Witherspoon (STL)
His speed is extremely underrated along with his awareness. Witherspoon is arguably one of the best players on the Rams defense, but he never gets credit. He is a reliable veteran who understands the game inside and out. He knows what must be done in certain situations and has the skill and speed to set up big plays. His ability to create turnovers individually has sadly passed, but he can still make an immediate impact for any ball club. Witherspoon is an all around underrated player who has just as much speed and awareness as some of the best.
22. Stephen Tulloch (TEN)
Tulloch might be one of the most unstable hitters today. He has an unorthodox style to his game and runs around like a mad man who escaped from prison. His mental focus is uncanny and his overall toughness is some of the best in the league. Tulloch can fly into holes like a missile and wrap up ball carriers very quickly. His consistency as a reliable player has improved for the most part and playing alongside Kieth Bullock should keep his high level of confidence up. Tulloch is an amazing athlete that should bring a scary presence to any opposing offense; and if you don’t think he is, then he has already beaten you.
23. Channing Crowder (MIA)
Crowder has developed very nicely these past few years. He has become a more aware player with much better tackling and pursuing skills from when he first entered the league. Learning the position from Joey Porter doesn’t hurt either. Crowder has the ability to become a Pro Bowl player for a consistent amount of time. His athletic talent combined with his NFL developmental skills can transform this once mediocre player into a superstar in the future. If Crowder continues his development, I see one of the most confident, hard hitting, aware backers the league will see down the road.
24. Zach Thomas (KC)
Thomas can still produce solidly for any team he is on. The Chiefs needed a reliable veteran to help guide the young but improving Kansas City defense. His presence might make everyone else on that team better (like Jarrad Page), but he can’t do it himself. Thomas is as blue-collar as they come and can still read a play better than most backers. His overall quickness and speed has never been impressive, but it has slowly gotten worse each season. Thomas still has the skill and mentality to produce for the Kansas City defense, but his speed can not match with the young talent in the game today.
25. Lawrence Timmons (PIT)
Expect a huge season from Lawrence Timmons. He is a fast, explosive and tough backer who has athletic potential through the roof. He took Larry Foote’s job, so he obviously has impressed someone in Pittsburgh. His hitting skills are very impressive, but can still improve. To sum it all up, Timmons is a solid player who is still working on the little things to become great. His athletic talent and play making ability has been proven already in my opinion.
26. Andra Davis (DEN)
This was a one time play maker who has seemed to fall off the map due to injuries. Davis has some of the best tackling mechanics and play recognition skills. He has always played with a chip on his shoulder which makes him more dangerous to me. His tough attitude and hard working demeanor can make Davis a consistent player like he once was in Cleveland. It is the same case with Thomas, I’m just not sure his athletic talent matches up with his football skills. Davis has the potential to return to a dominant force on defense, but he will have to play harder than he has ever before played in his career to seriously get back on that level.
27. Eric Barton (NYJ)
He is an underrated blitzer who can set up big play opportunities for his teammates. Barton has low-key speed that surprises many opposing blockers. His ability to come up and make a play on the run is not the best, but manageable. Barton, I believe, is most effective coming from the outside rather than inside. His pure strength does not match to other inside backers, but his overall football skill still allows him to be a presence on the field. He is an effective player who I feel would be used to his best potential on the outside rather than in.
28. Nick Barnett (GB)
It was hard to rank Barnett this low. He is still one of the best pure hitters on defense and is a reliable player to fill open holes at the line. Injuries scare me for Barnett more than any other player I can think of (which might be why he is ranked pretty low). It’s not that I’m not confident in Barnett’s consistency or proven skill; but I feel he has played up to the best he is going to get. The fact that he struggled and got hurt last year really makes me fear for his future as a top backer again.
29. Stephen Cooper (SD)
Cooper is another linebacker who hits like a man and runs around like a mad one. He brings a tough and unorthodox style to his game that is effective. Cooper does a good job of running through ball carriers with a determination and technique that almost seems flawless. The intensity he shows in every aspect of his game makes me think high for him and the future. Cooper has never really gotten the chance to prove he can become a reliable long-term player for a franchise. He has the ability, talent, mindset and mechanics to deliver solid performances week in and week out.
30. Paul Posluszny (BUF)
This play might develop into his own this season. He is a hard working player with as much toughness as pure aggression. His quickness and explosive abilities are weak compared to other backers in the league and on his team. He does a pretty solid job of filling the inside role for Buffalo, and the talent around him only enhances his confidence and success. Posluszny has the best attitude and mentality coaches like in their players, but his overall performance in the league up to this point has not even come close to what he is actually capable of doing. I like everything about Posluszny other than his pure football skill compared to most players he lines up against.
31. Leon Williams (CLE) – A under-the-radar player who has had great success in the 3-4. He can fill holes extremely well and delivers a big body presence to the field.
32. Gary Brackett (IND) – Brackett is a smart player who is always thinking about making the big play. He is one of the best linebackers at executing what he wants to accomplish on a play.
33. David Harris (NYJ) – Another reliable veteran who fills in as one of the best role players on defense.
34. Larry Foote (DET) – Although he lost his job in Pittsburgh, he is still one of the most underrated athletes with great awareness. He might have been the missing piece in Detroit’s new and improved line backing core.
35. Rey Maualuga (CIN) – Another candidate for defensive rookie of the year. Brings the same toughness and emotion that players like Ray Lewis and EJ Henderson show.
36. Stewart Bradley (PHI) – This may be a low ranking to many. Bradley has become a dependable play maker in clutch situations of a game. His tackling skills are underrated, but his presence is widely recognized.
37. Takeo Spikes (SF) – He might find success this year (mainly because of Singletary). He is still a fiery player with a winning mindset. His toughness and skill shave not gone anywhere and I think this season is an opportunity for him to prove it.
38. Tedy Bruschi (NE) – Still a productive player for a franchise who specializes in using their talents the best way possible. As long as he is healthy and active, Bruschi will always help rather than hurt a defense.
39. Nate Webster (DEN) – He disappointed me a lot last season. His big hits seemed to come and go, but missed more tackles than made. He has the potential to play consistently productive, but the signing of Andra Davis might mean Denver wasn’t too impressed with him either.
40. Napoleon Harris (MIN) – He can make big plays from time to time, but rarely sees the field due to EJ Henderson’s dominance. Henderson does get hurt more times than none, so his PT shouldn’t get in the way of what he can deliver each week.
Published: July 11, 2009
Ranking the leagues best players at the safety position, entering the 09′ season
1. Ed Reed (BAL)
I believe Reed should’ve won league MVP last season. Baltimore’s success last year obviously came from the defensive side of the football. Although Lewis is the true leader of that defense, Reed is the biggest play maker. He is a threat to pick any ball off at any time and can take it the distance with ease.
He is arguably one of the hardest hitting dudes and consistently produces every year. His speed, aggression and pure athletic talent make Reed one of the best safeties to ever play the game.
2. Troy Polamalu (PIT)
As a Steeler fan, it is hard to put Polamalu behind Reed. Troy is another defensive player who has MVP capabilities. He is always looking for a knock out blow that usually dismantles an entire offense’s flow. His leaping ability and quick change in direction allows him to cover a majority of the field.
He is a threat when blitzing and a straight head-hunter on the field. He is always looking to make a big play anyway he can. His awareness, aggression, skill and reliability make Polamalu one of the most valuable players on defense today.
3. Adrian Wilson (ARI)
Other than Reed, Wilson is the most athletic safety in the league. He has the best leaping ability, which makes it tough for quarterbacks to throw deep on. His body size and speed combine for a dangerous threat for any receiver running his way. He does a good job of reading plays and not giving up big passing plays.
He is quick enough to position himself as a pass defender, then run up and stop the run at the line of scrimmage (sometimes the backfield). Wilson is another safety who is a threat in the blitzing game, and has proven he take over as a leader on defense.
4. Bob Sanders (IND)
Sanders is capable of making almost any play on the field. He has MVP quality talent with some of the best knowledge. Sanders is quick enough to come stop the run and can come from almost any direction on field.
He is a heat-seeking missile when plays are made underneath him, which makes him so dangerous. His pass coverage ability is not as strong as hit hitting game though, but the cover two defense allows him to play the zone decently for the most part.
His one-on-one coverage with receivers deep down the field is one way to beat this guy, but he does a good job of keeping everything in front of him where he is able to create a big play for his defense.
5. OJ Atogwe (STL)
OJ is a very underrated defensive back in the league. Maybe it’s because he plays on the St. Louis Rams; but whatever the case, Atogwe is a big play maker who can give the needed spark to his team.
Atogwe is a very smart defender who sees the field very clearly. He understands what most receivers are trying to do in passing situations; and if he is able to make a play, he will. He is very reliable in the passing game and has the play making ability that surprises many teams.
I haven’t seen much from him in the tackling game, but that could be due to my limited viewing of Rams’ games last season.
6. Laron Landry (WAS)
Landry is probably feared by every offensive player except Brandon Jacobs. Landry has the speed, acceleration and toughness to take out any receiver in his path. He is a threat for turnovers with his ability to force fumbles.
Landry can make interceptions, but his hitting game is overall better than his coverage skills. He rarely gives up big plays and usually makes good decisions on the ball. A reliable safety to have patrol your secondary and a tough mindset make Landry a top talent and play maker in the league.
7. Brian Dawkins (DEN)
I don’t believe age is an issue with Brian Dawkins. He is still the same crazy, scary and determined player he was in Philadelphia. Dawkins can get to almost any spot on the football field with the mindset of crushing whoever is in his path.
Dawkins is not afraid of anyone and will take advantage of any clear shot opportunity. His ability to create turnovers has slowly disappeared each season, but he is still a threat to any offense.
Overall, Dawkins is a smart, reliable, proven leader that can help make any defense successful.
8. Michael Griffin (TEN)
This is another underrated safety who has killer instincts and amazing coverage skills. Griffin has developed into a smart and confident player with tons of talent around him to improve his success.
Griffin has come into his own at the safety position and could be a superstar in two or three more years. Griffin will put his head down to separate the ball from the receiver and has the ability to pick a lot of balls off.
He is a threat to individual receivers with his turnover abilities which makes him a serious opponent for other offenses.
9. Kerry Rhodes (NYJ)
Ranking Rhodes at number nine could be considered a low ranking. Rhodes is one of the more complete all around safeties in the game today. He has some of the best football knowledge and skill combined.
He understands what offenses like to do in certain situations and has already proven his reliability as a play maker on a consistent basis. He is always a threat to come up with big plays in crucial situations and can take advantage of any mistakes made by quarterbacks or receivers.
I still believe playing under Ryan will only enhance his game to the next level, which may be scary to think about. Rhodes is an under-the-radar player who is playing at a Pro Bowl status, but I think Ryan will bring out the absolute best in him (which I don’t think we’ve seen yet).
10. Nick Collins (GB)
As much as I don’t think Collins deserves a top ten ranking, he is better than the guys listed below him. He had the most interceptions in the league last year and can hit as well as some linebackers.
Collins is faster than what most people think and can surprise you with his ability to create big plays for his defense. His awareness is improving every year, which will make him a serious contender as a top safety.
I don’t think Collins is a top safety right now, but his attitude and work ethic towards football makes him a very dangerous player in the future. He will never give up on a play and will take risks to make the big play. I would trust Collins as a reliable safety given a couple of more years of maturity.
Then I would be completely sold on Collins ability to help lead a defense deep into season on a consistent basis.
11. Reggie Nelson (JAC)
Nelson’s biggest attribute is his athletic talent. His overall game took a step back last year, but he has the athletic talent and tough attitude to bounce back nicely. Nelson is a threat to make big plays from time to time, but not on a seriously consistent level. His leaping skills are impressive along with his hands and speed.
He seemed out of position on most plays last year and he played at an almost laid back approach. Nelson needs to be more aggressive this year, which he has proven to be in the past.
Overall, he as athletic and tough as they come; but that’s where his mind needs to be this year where it wasn’t last.
12. Antoine Bethea (IND)
Bethea struggled greatly towards the end of last year. He seemed out of position most of the time and could not tackle to save his life. As an overall safety though, Bethea is one of the smartest in the game with the skills to make everyone around him better.
He usually makes good breaks on the football and has some of the best pursuit skills as a defensive back. Bethea is a reliable player to be around the big play, but struggled to actually make it towards the end of last year.
13. Ken Hamlin (DAL)
Hamlin might be the most under-valued safeties in the league. Hamlin has one of the biggest builds in the secondary and can take off like a jet plane. His ability to come up and make a play on the run makes him a dangerous safety. He can take most receivers today one-on-one (from a tackling stand point) and has the athleticism to make big plays consistently.
Having DeMarcus pressure quarterbacks helps add to the success of his game and usually produces when given the opportunity more times than none. His attitude might surprise many; because whether he shows it or not, Hamlin plays with tons of fire and energy.
His coverage in the deep game is a bigger weakness than quality, but shouldn’t take away from how good he really is from an overall stand point.
14. Jarrad Page (KC)
Page is actually a decent football player on the Kansas City defense. Page understands the game inside and out and does a good job of positioning himself on plays. I wish he had better corners or pass rushers around him to bring out his full potential.
His overall game to this point though is very under-looked. Page can cover as well as any safety today and can make a big play when you least expect it. His overall mechanics and fundamentals need work, but his overall game was so much better than it was at the beginning of the year.
Page is an improving player who was over-looked last season. This is a player who doesn’t think too much, but goes where he is supposed to be and reacts well.
15. Jermaine Phillips (TB)
To me, Phillips is one of the most feared safeties. His strength is ridiculous along with his peed and desire to crush anything in his path. He runs downhill on almost every play and can create fumbles as well as any other safety.
His coverage skills are not as good as his hitting, but he still produces nicely for the most part. Phillips’ speed is often over-looked as a serious threat in his arsenal, but the combination of his power and athletic talent make Phillips a target to avoid for many receivers going over the middle.
16. Donte Whitner (BUF)
Without a doubt Donte Whitner is the most over-rated safety today. Other than pick one or two balls off, what has he really done? His tackling skills are decent at best and his height makes him an easy target to throw over. His leaping ability doesn’t make up for his height (like many other safeties or corners).
His coverage skills are overall solid, but he is out of position more times than none. I would put McKelvin and McGee over Whitner from an overall defensive back stand point.
Other than Whitner’s speed and big (but usually irrelevant) play from time to time, I haven’t seen anything displayed from Whitner that would make me think he is a serious safety to contend with in the league.
17. Antrell Rolle (ARI)
Rolle has the athletic talent to become a superstar in the league. He has some of the best speed and coverage skills in the game. The fact that he is lined up as a safety kind of gives him a head start when covering many receivers. He can make a big play when he is around the football, but needs to do a better job of play recognition.
Rolle’s tackling is weak but continues to get better as the season moves on. Playing alongside with Wilson shouldn’t hurt Rolle and playing on one of the most athletic defenses should only help elevate his game to a higher standard as he continues to learn the position ( remember he was a corner, so he is still transitioning).
18. Darren Sharper (NO)
Sharper is a reliable veteran who can still make big plays for any defense he is on. Sharper’s covering skills are still as precise as they come and his ability to create interceptions hasn’t faded either.
Sharper’s speed continues to drop each season. Many receivers can out run Sharper if they run the right route. Any short-cut or sit-down routes ran near Sharper is guaranteed to be picked off or unsuccessful.
His ability to read plays is another quality he holds and can lead a young group of defensive groups for the most part. I don’t know how consist Sharper can still be, but the defensive line in Minnesota is better than in New Orleans. His success might not be so consistent this year, but he should be overall solid for a majority of the season.
19. Tanard Jackson (TB)
Jackson in another safety on the rise because of his pure athletic talent. Jackson has some of the best toughness and play recgonition at such a young age. Playing next to Phillips gives Tampa two of the most feared safeties in the league.
Jackson makes nice breaks on the ball whether the play is short or deep. He is always looking to use his power to separate the ball from receiver (which I love from the safety position). He can work on his overall ability to cover receivers straight up, but overall he is a young talent with a bright future
.
20. Jim Leonhard (BAL)
This guy was brought to Baltimore with no intention of starting. Once Landry was hurt, Leonhard filled in for his role. Leonhard is one of the hardest playing safeties in the league. He has under-rated skills in every category. He is fast, quick, explosive and fearless. he has proven his play maker ability last year by picking off many passes that were in his range.
The talent around him bring out the best in Jim Leonhard and he could develop into a top safety in the league given confidence shown by the Baltimore organization.
21. Gibril Wilson (MIA)
Gibril is a proven winner with the ability to make big plays for a defense. Wilson’s athletic talent is rare to find and he if the perfect player for a Bill Parcells’ ran organization. Wilson’s success came from his days in New York, and now that Parcells runs Miami, Wilson can adapt to a more comfortable atmosphere.
He is a hard working player with more talent than awareness. Wilson’s weakness might come from the fact that he tries to do too much in certain situations (which can hurt a defense), but you’d much rather see a player do too much than too little.
22. Brandon Merriweather (NE)
Merriweather has all the athletic talent you want in a football player. He is fast, strong, has great leaping ability and a tough attitude. His awareness should be higher than what it actually is right now. I am not concerned about his job this season or next, but to say he has secured his role as a long-term safety for New England is ridiculous.
Merriweather’s knowledge of the safety position needs to improve rather than his overall football knowledge.
23. Tyrell Johnson (MIN)
The league is full of young athletic safeties that are superstars of the future, Tyrell is another. His ability to hit and his height make him a threat to many receivers trying to hit deep to intermediate routes.
His focus and determination improves each year along with his confidence. His coverage skills need to be worked on (now that Sharper is gone).
I don’t think he can take over the safety position for a team right now, but he has the mentality and physical skill to do so in the future.
24. Deon Grant (SEA)
Grant is a reliable player who can come up with big plays from time to time. He is obviously well passed his prime, but can continue to be a successful piece to any defense.
Grant reads the field better than many safeties; and if he had the speed, could make a play on many balls. He usually breaks well enough on players to wrap them up, but his ability to get in front of receivers fast enough are long behind him.
Still an effective player to have, just not as effective as he has proven to be.
25. Madieu Williams (MIN)
This is a good replacement for Sharper’s departure. He is a fundamental player with more athletic ability than knowledge. Williams is a safety who does the little mechanics correctly.
He usually positions himself to make smart decisions, but has a habit for trying to do too much at one time. Although he is a great talent, Williams (from time to time) will try to make a play that he has no business of even trying. That can hurt defenses a lot of time, but he is now on a team that will give him way less responsibilities.
I like Williams filling in Minnesota, but the should keep an eye on him and possibly start preparing to replace him in the near future.
26. Sean Jones (PHI)
Jones has the opportunity to become a breakout player this season. He is now on a great defensive team with a great coordinator who will use him to his potential. As far as what I’ve seen from him in Cleveland, Jones is a talented safety with the potential to become great. He is strong, physical and can cover pretty decently.
His overall aggression and attitude seemed laid back in Cleveland, but that might change with his new team. Plain and simple, this is a player with tons of potential who was just in a bad situation in Cleveland.
From what he displayed in Cleveland, it is hard to rank him any higher; but don’t be surprised if he played like a Pro Bowl talent (because he is more than capable).
27. Eugene Wilson (HOU)
Wilson is a solid safety who can make a big play for your defense every now and then. He is well past his prime when he played in New England, but he might need to become a more dominant player in Houston.
Wilson has the ability to take over and lead a secondary, but as of recent years he hasn’t. Injuries are the main concern with Eugene Wilson; but overall he is still a solid and reliable player who can hit and cover very well.
28. Brodney Pool (CLE)
Here is an athletic talent that has yet to prove himself as a reliable player short-term or long. His pure athletic talent, I think is what is keeping this man a starter. He has great speed and size but uses it completely wrong.
His fundamentals and awareness is some of the worse, but all of that is fixable. Pool is a player with tons of potential from a talent stand point, but other than that he has a lot to work on if he wants to continue as a starter in this league.
29. Dawan Landry (BAL)
Although Leonhard won his starting role, Dawan Landry is still one of the most productive safeties out there. His combination of toughness and speed help overlook the challenges he faces with his height. Landry can start for almost any team in the league, let alone a back up for Baltimore.
Landry brings a great attitude and work ethic to the field and his play reflects that. His overall talent and determination make Landry a dangerous player to face, but not as serious as some of the best.
30. Ryan Clark (PIT)
Clark played extremely well toward the end of last season. Honestly, it was the best ball I’ve seen from him. He played fearless and confident with almost a chip on his shoulder. He is an intelligent safety with limited athletic ability.
Clark has turned into a crazy dog over the years, delivery an unorthodox style to his game. He has tendencies to get beat deep down the field, but can make big plays when needed. An overall reliable defender, but can give up big plays just as much as he can make them.
31. James Butler (NYG)
Another reliable player who does a good job of filling his role. Butler does what is asked of him and has some of the best raw talent. His aggression and confidence is lacking, which can separate him from becoming an under-the-radar player to a top name.
He can hit just as well as many safeties and rarely misses tackles. His coverage skills are par, but the defensive line he has elevates his success to a high level. Butler is a complete player that could be more dangerous if he went all out every play every week.
32. Quintin Mikell (PHI)
Mikell had a decent season last year, but not a spectacular one. His quickness and agility separate himself from most safeties and plays with a lurking attitude. He seems like he knows what he is going to do before he does it and sets up receivers to make mistakes.
His tackling skills improved the more I watched him and has the skills set to become a top defender next season. He needs to prove his consistency this year though, especially now that Dawkins is no longer playing next to him. Mikell will have to step up as the leader, which I think he will given time.
33. Danieal Manning (CHI)
Here is another corner converted safety. Manning has some of the best coverage skills in the game along with speed. As a safety, I’m not sure how this will work. I haven’t seen any aggression from Manning’s game in the past, but he does have big play capabilities that can hurt offenses if they over-look him.
Manning can pop out of nowhere to make big plays on the football, but he will have to prove he can do it consistently at the safety position rather the corner.
34. Atari Bigby (GB)
You could rank Bigby higher, but he didn’t play well at all last season. He was injured from time to time, but Bigby played much better two years ago rather than last season. He can still hit as good as they come and has great acceleration to make a play on the ball. His quickness lacks compared to many receivers, so it is easy to take him out of position and throw over him.
His hustle and determination, along with his once proven skill, still makes Bigby a solid safety. If Bigby has one or two more years like last year though, he won’t be the starter in Green Bay much longer.
Overall he has as much athletic talent and potential to become a reliable number one for any team, I just don’ think we saw anything remotely close to that last year.
35. Jordan Babineaux (SEA)
I am being very generous giving Babineaux this high a ranking. He has struggled more times than be successful and hasn’t proven anything since signing that big deal a few years back.
36. Erik Coleman (ATL)
Coleman might be the new leader of the Falcon secondary. A reliable player who does what is asked. His level of crunkness surprised me last year.
37. Eric Weddle (SD)
An over-rated safety to say the least. He is fast enough to pursuit quickly but if supported heavily buy the talent around him.
38. Josh Bullocks (NO)
His impact during games comes and goes. He continues to get older, but can still come through for defenses from time to time.
39. Will Allen (TB)
He has under-achieved a majority of his career, but has been playing confident and more aware in recent years. Another former corner making the transition to safety.
40. Kenny Phillips (NYG)
A very athletic kid with a lot of awareness in his arsenal. After looking over the past two lists I created, I think the Giants secondary is the most under-rated.
41. Jason Allen (MIA)
A reliable veteran whose athletic talent does not match his actually football talent.
42. Paul Oliver (SD)
He has gotten much bigger than his days in Georgia. His speed and athletic talent are some of the best and now that he has size, he could be taking Hart’s starting spot by the end of the season.
43. William Moore (ATL)
Should surprise many this year. An athletic talent with a positive attitude can make Moore a dangerous player next season. If he can play confident and smart, then Moore will be just fine.
44. Mike Brown (KC)
His ability as a main threat for opposing offenses are long gone. The best he can do is fill into a role and play hard football. That could go either way for him at this point.
45. Michael Huff (OAK)
Huff has been a disappoint in his career so far, but not as bad as people say. He is still a physical player with a great attitude and approach to the game. If he could only create more big plays than his job might be a little more secure.
Published: July 10, 2009
Ranking the best overall corner backs in the league entering the 09′ season
1. Nnamdi Asomugha (OAK)
There is nothing to not like about this player. He has the best coverage skills in the league, makes smart decisions when the ball is in the air, and can come up to make the tackle.
His height separates himself from most corners in the league. He is a hard worker with a humble attitude to his game.
Asomugha is the type of corner that takes out an entire side of a football field (Primetime was another). Although Asomugha could be the best overall player on the Raiders, I still think Darren McFadden is the most athletic.
Regardless, he is one of the best pure football players in the league with a lot of years to go.
2. Champ Bailey (DEN)
If Asomugha didn’t develop so quickly, then I’d put Champ at number one. He has some of the best instincts in the league. This guy can cover almost any receiver, intercept any ball and tackle whoever comes near him.
Champ is the best wrap-up tackler at the corner position, but injuries did set him back last year. If Champ can stay healthy, he will produce. Bailey’s high intensity of play and the vast football knowledge he has shown throughout his career make him a threat to any receiver he is guarding.
Bailey is a player that makes your entire secondary better and can create big plays on a weekly basis.
3. Asante Samuel (PHI)
You can say he cost New England a Super Bowl win against New York, but the guy is still a play maker. Samuel continues to make big plays on a weekly basis and despite a top three ranking, could be viewed as underrated.
His hops are deceiving, and he can break a run after an interception. He covers receivers as well as any other corner, and can break on a ball very quickly.
Samuel jumps in front of defenders more than he straight up goes man-to-man, which can be tricky for opposing quarterbacks. He played extremely well last year and created a lot of big plays for the Eagle defense.
Overall, Samuel is a reliable play maker that comes up big more times than none.
4. Rashean Mathis (JAC)
Mathis has some of the best press coverage in the league. He is not afraid to get physical with receivers on the line or down the field. His speed is underrated and his awareness is one of the best in the league.
Mathis has the quickness and vision to break on most balls and make a play. Mathis has struggled recently with one-on-one deep coverage, but for the most part, he is a tough player with tons of athletic talent.
He has already proven his superstar talent more than once. Great leadership, intelligence, and Mathis’ overall talent make him one of the best defenders in the game today.
5. Nate Clements (SF)
He is another tough corner with coverage ability through the roof.
Nate will have his game or two where he just struggles, but he is arguably one of the toughest defenders to throw on. Clements’ tough mindset and great technique makes him a dangerous player to face.
He positions himself to make a play on both the ball and player, and at times can straight up knock folks out. He is a corner I would trust in big play situations to not only defend the pass, but stop the run.
Overall, Clements technique, talent, and toughness make him a solid number one for any team to have.
6. Terrence Newman (DAL)
Newman is very underrated when it comes to being a great corner back. His speed allows him to cover most receivers in the league, and his size gives him a better chance to make a play on one-on-one situations.
Newman has some of the best pure athletic talent in the league, and his knowledge on the field has continued to grow every year.
I would like to see Newman be more aggressive when the ball is in the air, but he is by far one of the biggest and fastest corners in the game today.
7. Charles Woodson (GB)
Woodson has really only played one or two bad seasons in his career. For the most part, Woodson is a proven talent who continues to makes plays for his defense.
Woodson is very smart by luring quarterbacks to throw his way; but when they do, he usually makes a play.
Woodson is not afraid to put his head down to make a play, and has some of the best tackling skills among any defender. He is without a doubt a leader on any defense, and can seriously help take a team deep into a post-season.
8. Darrelle Revis (NYJ)
Revis is on his way to becoming a top corner in the league. Despite his youth, he managed to play extremely well for a majority of the season.
He seemed to always be grabbing interception after interception, with the ability to take it the distance.
Revis’ technique was so impressive for his young age. He is an aggressive corner who will take the ball away at its highest point. He is a threat for any offense, and can surprise many with his style of play.
Beware of Darrelle Revis next season. His overall game was just so impressive to watch last year; and with Rex Ryan now in control of the defense, his game might be elevated to an even higher standard.
9. Al Harris (GB)
Harris is a reliable, veteran play maker who can play with pretty much any receiver in the league. He is another corner who has great technique in his coverage and tackling skills.
He is probably one of the most aware corners in the game, and can compete in many jump ball situations.
Harris is just a smart, reliable player with as much brains as talent. Any organization would love to have Harris as their number one, let alone a number two, in Green Bay.
10. Carlos Rogers (WAS)
Carlos Rogers has the attitude and ability to become a top corner in the league consistently. Rogers is a hard working talent who can read plays extremely well.
His ability to break is often over-looked and his hitting comes and goes. He is so reliable to have however, because he is a corner that will always make a play on the ball.
He has some of the best man-to-man coverage skills, but I haven’t really been impressed with his zone coverage.
Rogers’ awareness and ability to break on most balls makes him such a dangerous defender, but he does give up big plays from time to time (usually not touchdowns, however).
11. Antonie Winfield (MIN)
Winfield is probably the best impact hitting corner in the league. He does an excellent job of running downhill to stop the run and rarely lets receivers break tackles on him.
His height challenges his full potential, but overall he is as dangerous as they come. He is still able to make big plays in a game even if its not covering receivers.
Winfield has a habit for forcing fumbles and seems to be everywhere the ball is.
I guess that means he is good at pursuing the football, and shows he plays with a determined mindset that separates the men from the boys.
12. Terrence McGee (BUF)
He is another corner back whose size limits his full potential talent. McGee is very fast, and can get in between a receiver and the football in a blink of an eye.
His reads are very nice, along with his pure athletic talent.
Fundamentally, McGee still has someways to go. Other than McGee’s mechanics and fundamentals, he has superstar ability written all over him.
He is by far the best secondary player on Buffalo (NOT Donte Whitner). McGee’s impressive play, awareness and talent make him special. He still needs to learn better mechanics and become a more vocal leader, which I think he will.
13. Quentin Jammer (SD)
As a pure overall corner back, Jammer is better than Antonio Cromartie, which may be the reason he is listed as the number one and Cromartie the number two.
Jammer is fundamentally sound at the corner position, but he can also deliver knock out shots that’ll either waken or silence opponents.
His technique is almost flawless and does the little things right that make corners great. He knows when to run with a receiver, when to turn his head, how to position his body, and whether to go for the interception or just swat the ball away.
Jammer has the capability to change a game with one play (which he has done on more than one occasion). Jammer’s fundamental skills along with his toughness and awareness make Jammer a complete corner back.
14. Marcus Trufant (SEA)
After a shaky season last year, I think Trufant will bounce back nicely. Trufant is as dangerous as they come to create turnovers on a consistent basis.
He hasn’t done much to impress me in the tackling game, but his coverage skills are amazing. He as underrated leaping ability, along with long arms and big hands to snag balls that surprise many corners.
Turfant can go one-on-one with many receivers, and is not easily fooled. A smart corner to say the least, Trufant’s brilliant coverage skills make him a dangerous defender.
If you catch him out of position, even for a spilt second, he usually has a hard time recovering. Trufant usually positions himself nicely, though, to make the best play on the ball possible.
15. Antonio Cromartie (SD)
Athletically, this guy is a straight freak. His athleticism is one of the best in the game today. He can jump to the moon and extend even further.
Cromartie has play maker written all over him, and has proven so on numerous occasions.
Cromartie’s awareness and football knowledge is a weakness, but it continues to improve each season. Playing alongside with Quentin Jammer and a returning Shawne Merriman shouldn’t hurt his chances at success either.
Cromartie is a threat to change a game every time he’s on the field. Cromartie is never looking for the knock out blow (like Jammer), but he usually does a good job of wrapping up and making plays on the run.
His size also gives him an advantage when covering most receivers.
16. Chris Gamble (CAR)
Gamble could be the most underrated back in the league. He is a straight beast on the field and displays warrior-like tactics when he plays. He is not afraid to cover any receiver, or hit any opponent right in the jaw.
Gamble plays with a chip on his shoulder like he has something to prove. He is quicker than most people give credit and can make a play on the ball as good as they come.
He has a great chance of winning many jump ball situations, and has a very aware reading of the field. His games lacks consistency, but if he can play up to his full potential each week, Gamble would be in Honolulu every year.
17. Sheldon Brown (PHI)
He is a short corner with a tough attitude. His ability to hit and separate the ball from receivers is rare to find.
His height is a weakness in my mind, but his hops and ability to create turnovers make him a threat to many offenses. He is another corner you can beat with one misstep (mainly because of his size).
Brown has the ability to make just as many big plays as Samuel, but I would bet more times than none that receivers (like Moss, Fitzgerald, the Johnson’s, etc.) have a much better chance for success against Brown than against Samuel.
18. Dominque Rogers-Cromartie (ARI)
He is the fastest corner in the league. DRC surprised me last season, though, because he was making big play after big play.
I didn’t believe he would come into the league and dominate the way he did last season. like Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco—he can only get better, right?
His awareness and football knowledge will only improve and his athletic ability will go nowhere. DRC can jump, run, defend and surprise many offenses.
His tackling way decent but not reliable. Overall, he is a young talent who surprised many with his dominance, and has only a bright future ahead of him.
19. Ike Taylor (PIT)
Taylor is one of the best coverage corners in the game. His height is hard to find in the league, and he is the perfect pass defending corner.
He can keep up with most receivers; and if he is even in his receivers range, Taylor will knock it away more times than none. Taylor can hit along with every other Pittsburgh defensive player.
His leaping ability also adds to his success in the coverage game, but he can lose many one-on-one battles if he gets beat off of the line of scrimmage. Taylor has proven his ability, though (has two Super Bowl rings), and is considered, in my eyes, as a reliable corner in this league.
20. Cedric Griffin (MIN)
Griffin can start for many NFL teams. The fact that he is a number two corner, let alone on the Minnesota Vikings, is just too scary to think about.
Griffin is a big time play maker who scares receivers with his style of play. He will knock opponents out and then let them know about when they get up. He is very elusive in the secondary, which surprises me, because his size and power is so great.
His ability to create turnovers are often over-looked.
Griffin is a rare gem in this league, and will become a superstar in the league one day.
He has a killer mindset that separates his game from may other corners. His mental and physical approach to the game is what makes any defense successful.
21. Cortland Finnegan (TEN)
Finnegan is a straight brawler on the field. He doesn’t care who is lined up in front of him—He will go 100% and then some.
I think his turnovers were lucky last year, and I still have questions about his overall coverage game. He is a very physical defender and is tough to get by when he is in the press. He reminds me of a young Antoine Winfield, with a lot about coverage to learn.
His fundamental and mechanics improved each game last year, but I still think that defensive line made the secondary better (not to mention Griffin and Hope backing you up).
If Finnegan can produce the same way he did last year and become a reliable player to cover other teams number one receiver, then I am completely inside and out sold on this kid’s future success.
22. Leon Hall (CIN)
Leon Hall made a couple of big plays here and there last year, but to rank him above half of the guys listed is ridiculous.
Hall can cover decently which is the same for his tackling game. He has some athletic talent, but has that aggressive attitude with a chip on his shoulder.
Hall is another player out to prove that he is more than a one year wonder (if you can call it that). His first year in the league was just so bad that it is hard for me to see him make that type of leap and consistently stay there.
If he does, more power to him though. Last year he showed he has the potential to become a play maker; but this year, he must do it again and possibly take his game to a higher level.
If people are saying Hall is a top ten corner in this league, then he must be the leader of that defense (right now, he is NOT).
23. Nick Harper (TEN)
If you would rank Nick Harper over Finnegan, I wouldn’t argue. Harper has just as much fire in his game as Finnegan, but does a better job of recognition in coverage.
Harper’s speed can be decisive and his IQ is one of the best. Harper’s ability to run down field with most receivers is hard to come by these days.
I like to think of him as the Derrick Mason on defense—proven, reliable, hard worker, fast, smart, under-valued but one hell of a football player that I would want on my team.
24. Ronde Barber (TB)
I am still wondering if Barber can tackle DeAngelo Williams. Jokes aside, Barber has been a consistent player throughout his entire career.
He has played successfully through injuries, makes smart decisions on the ball and does a good job of tackling. Barber can still make big plays for a defense, but I think his game-changing plays are behind him.
Barber has been one of the smartest and most talented corners I have seen. He brings a fun, laid back but aggressive attitude to his game. His skills have seemed to quietly disappear each year, and I wonder how much longer he will continue.
25. Charles Tillman (CHI)
Tillman has the potential to become a top defender in this league; he is just one of the most inconsistent players I’ve witnessed play.
Apart from his inconsistency. Tillman has amazing speed with a nose for the football.
His breaks are quick, precise and on time. His coverage skills are also impressive and he can go one-on-one with many receivers.
His big plays come and go (along with his game), but is overall a pretty decent number one who has proven his talent deep into a post-season.
26. Lito Sheppard (NYJ)
Sheppard might have a very successful under-the-radar year. Revis does get all the attention in New york, but Lito is just as talented and skilled.
Having Ryan in charge of the defense should bring confidence to any player, including Sheppard. He is little, but has mad hops and not too shabby hands. He can read plays extremely well and has vast knowledge of the game inside and out.
Lito has the ability to be a top defender and has big play potential every time he sees the field. If everything in New York goes according to plan, Sheppard could find himself in Honolulu at the end of the year, because his ability is that good.
27. Fred Bennett (HOU)
A lot of people have not heard of Fred Bennett. He is a blue-collar player with an attitude that every coach wants in a defensive player.
His coverage skills are over-looked, and he is not afraid to go one-on-one many times. Bennett is still young and has a lot about the game to learn, but his pure athletic talent and potential shown makes him a superstar in the making.
Bennett will be a household name in the future, but he needs more development time. He is the number one in Houston though, so how much more time does he really need?
28. Aaron Ross (NYG)
I think ranking Ross this low is kind of an insult. He had just as successful of a rookie year as Revis did.
Ross can make big plays in key situations of a game, and has the speed and agility to take any ball he picks off to the crib.
His size and athletic talent combine for a dangerous skill set many corners don’t hold. He is another young corner on the rise, and plays for an organization that will help him achieve success.
29. Rodrick Hood (ARI)
Hood is another underrated corner. Though he doesn’t have a lot of size, it shouldn’t matter because he can hit like a linebacker and jump extremely high.
Hood always positions himself to make the best play possible, but only executes a few times during a game. He is always a threat to jump up and make a surprising play, but I would take many receivers over him on one-on-one coverage.
His knowledge, athleticism and toughness makes him a decent play maker, but not a consistent one.
30. Anthony Henry (DET)
Henry is another reliable veteran that always makes the right decisions. Henry knows what do and where to be in almost every play. He can hit, cover and mess with a quarterback’s mind.
Henry should always be taken seriously as a great one-on-one corner with the ability to make everyone else around him better.
Now that he is on a young Detroit team, his talent and leadership could make both himself and the Lions better.
31. Fabian Washington (BAL)
I’m not sure how he lost his job in Oakland. He always played well, and made plays from time to time.
His game has obviously improved since then, but Fabian is not the guy I would trust guarding the outside of my field. His technique and fundamental coverage skills are very nice, but I feel many running backs (and some receivers) would not hesitate to run right over or around him.
He is a quick and explosive player in the air game, which is what really matters at the corner position. He is a reliable number two at best, but fits in well with the Baltimore defense (taking Chris McAlister’s spot).
32. Chris Houston (ATL)
I don’t understand why people don’t like Chris Houston. He is a tough, tall, fast and smart corner who gives little separation between himself and the receiver.
I would actually trust Houston with one-on-one coverage over many corners listed above. He runs well with receivers and does a good job of never loosing them.
His fundamentals and awareness continue to improve each year.
Houston’s weakness is that he never gets his head around in time to actually see and make a play on the ball. I think Houston will learn that as time goes on; and with an improving Falcon team and defensive line, Houston’s time to shine might be sooner than expected.
33. Ken Lucas (CAR)
Lucas has progressively gotten worse each season, until last year, during which he pretty much saved his career by playing his tail off.
He has the potential to start for a couple of teams, but he fits in perfectly as the number two corner in the Carolina defense.
He can cover most receivers and plays just as hard as his opposite Gamble. His speed may surprise many, but Lucas is more of just a role player than he is an overall cornerback.
34. Patrick Surtain (KC)
Surtain’s talent at the corner position is among the best. He can make many plays on the ball when given the chance. Surtain has been getting beat deep as of recent memory, but his intensity and talent is still there.
With a new defensive scheme, Surtain might have one more chance to prove he still has the talent he displayed in Miami.
35. Kelvin Hayden (IND)
Hayden is one of the more aware corners in the game. He is always looking to make the big play to spark a defense. His covering skills are average, but his football talent and recognition on plays makes him a dangerous player.
His skill is slowly progressing however, and I’m not sure what to expect from him now that coach Tony Dungy is gone.
Hayden is always a reliable player to have and will always go for the home run on most plays. Sometimes it backfires, but Hayden is always aware of the situation on the field and reacts better than most corners.
36. Mike Jenkins (DAL)
The future is bright for Jenkins, who plays opposite one of the best corners in the league and has the potential to become better. His awareness improved greatly towards the end of the season and his athletic ability is among the league’s best.
Although his awareness seemed to improve, he still has a lot to learn and it definitely showed on the field. I expect a much more aggressive and confident Jenkins this year, which could set him up for success down the road.
37. Andre Goodman (MIA)
Goodman is a very quiet corner who makes big plays from time to time. Goodman positions himself very nicely on most plays and is not afraid hit, either. His agility and quickness are often overlooked, which makes him dangerous for quarterbacks and receivers.
He is just an underestimated player in many teams’ eyes, but has the ability to hurt any team’s offense if they don’t take him as a serious threat.
38. Chris McAlister (BAL)
I am surprised to see McAlister slip on the Baltimore depth chart—I mean, he did help bring that city a Super Bowl trophy.
That is in the past, however, and regardless of what I might think of McAlister as a pure corner, he is no longer the number one. McAlister can still cover a majority of the receivers today and hit just like those Raven linebackers.
McAlister is always a threat to make a big play by creating or taking advantage of turnovers. This year, McAlister will probably be used as a reliable role player to help cushion this defense until the postseason.
I think McAlister will be more useful in the postseason than the regular—if Baltimore makes a playoff appearance.
39. Leigh Bodden (NE)
Bodden individually did not struggle in Cleveland; the secondary as a whole struggled.
Bodden still has the talent and potential to make big plays for any defense. He is now in a place where they will use his skills the right way for the benefit of that defense.
Bodden is a great talent, and will be used to his fullest potential in New England (just like every player).
Bodden can match-up one-on-one with many receivers and has great athletic ability to create turnovers. Expect a solid and productive year from Bodden—possibly the best you’ve seen from him.
40. Jason David (NO) – A reliable corner who can help defenses, but hurt them, too. He has a habit for giving up big plays down field in crucial situations. Overall, though, he is a solid corner.
41. Eric Wright (CLE) – He needs more maturity and knowledge to become successful, but his athletic skill shouldn’t be questioned.
42. Ellis Hobbs (PHI) – We will see how effective he can be with limited playing time. His height is a weakness, but can make a play if needed.
43. Tim Jennings (IND) – He is very underrated corner with a lot to prove this season. His game is a little soft, but he does seem to be in the right place at the right time.
44. Dunta Robinson (HOU) – He is another underrated corner with leaping ability through the roof. He can make big plays at random points in a game (and is in my profile picture too).
45. Deshea Townsend (PIT) – Deshea is overrated, if you ask me. He is a short corner who can defend decently, but gives up more plays than makes.
46. Nathan Vasher (CHI) – His speed and athletic ability are very nice, but his consistency and big play capability have seemed to fade the past year or two.
47. Corey Webster (NYG) – Webster is always a relaible player who will go hard every play. His defensive line makes him better than he actually is, but he can still ball.
48. Aqib Talib (TB) – Talib might be a dark horse in the league this year. He is a tough, athletic kid with a lot to learn to become consistently successful.
49. DeAngelo Hall (WAS) – Hall is a complete plane crash from where he was in Atlanta. He can still make plays—just not as much anymore, now that he is on a team with infinite cornerbacks.
50. Leodis McKelvin (BUF) – He should be WAY higher on this list. McKelvin has unbelievable athletic ability, great awareness, and play making capability at such a young age.
51. Fakhir Brown (STL)
52. Jonathan Wade (STL)
53. Vontae Davis (MIA)
54. Brandon Flowers (KC)
55. Jonathan Joesph (CIN)
56. Walt Harris (SF)
57. Josh Wilson (SEA)
58. Brian Williams (JAC)
59. Jacques Reeves (HOU)
60. Chevis Jackson (ATL)
Published: July 9, 2009
Ranking the league’s best overall tight ends entering the 2009 season.
1. Tony Gonzalez (ATL)
Gonzalez is already believed by many to be the greatest tight end to ever play the game.
He is easily one of the top receivers in the league with his ability to run routes, catch balls, block for the run, and separate himself from defenders.
One thing that makes Gonzalez unique is his consistency. Gonzo has consistently produced Pro Bowl numbers each year in his career. He has consistently been the No. 1 target his entire career and has shown no signs of regressing from his game.
This is a guy hungry for a ring, however, and he realizes it is possible with the offensive talent in Atlanta. This move will not only make Gonzalez a better player, but the entire offense as well.
2. Jason Witten (DAL)
Any team would want a player like Jason Witten.
He is a strong, physical player with a determination to score every time he touches the ball. He is not afraid to take a big hit over the middle, and will produce consistent numbers on a weekly basis. Being Romo’s No. 1 target doesn’t hurt your stats either.
The departure of Terrell Owens will open more looks for Witten, and the Dallas running game should take pressure off of him during games.
As long as Witten is on the field, expect Pro Bowl numbers all the time.
3. Antonio Gates (SD)
Injuries have set Gates back in recent years, but he has already proven himself as one of the most athletic tight ends in the game today.
He can box out any defender and burn most linebackers trying to cover him, his leaping ability is through the roof, and his hands are as good as they come.
There isn’t much to hate about Gates, other than he hasn’t seen the field as much as I’d like, especially because he is still young.
Gates is always a threat to make big plays and a reliable target for an explosive offense.
4. Dallas Clark (IND)
Other than Gonzalez, Dallas Clark runs routes better than any other tight end.
He has the perfect connection with his quarterback Peyton Manning and can easily create throwing lanes for him as well. Clark will catch almost any pass and is not distracted by extra defenders guarding him.
He is a tough and solid player who has proven his reliability and consistency in his short time as a professional.
5. Kellen Winslow (TB)
No one should question Winslow’s athletic ability or toughness on the field.
His attitude towards the game is perfect, and the talent he displays (when healthy) is one of the best in the league. He can win most one-on-one battles with any linebacker or defensive back, and even if Winslow is covered, if the ball is thrown his way, he still has the better chance of snagging it over the defender.
The talent and toughness this guy has physically and mentally makes him one of the best pure athletes in the game of football today.
6. Chris Cooley (WAS)
Cooley is one of the undersized tight ends in the league, but that doesn’t stop him from competing at a high level of intensity every week.
Cooley is a tough, smart, and confident player that is reliable in certain situations in a game. He knows where to go at certain times and surprises many defenders with his agility and elusiveness.
His range for catching is another surprising element to his arsenal, and he can change the pace of a game with one play.
He is a hard worker with as much skill in him as desire.
7. Heath Miller (PIT)
Miller is the toughest tight end in the game today.
He has the perfect size to block, catch, and run with a motor that keeps on running. He has surprisingly nice hands that make him a threat on third down and red zone situations. He can run the seam route on most linebackers and has developed into the perfect utility player for the Pittsburgh offense.
Miller is an all-around tight end with basically no flaws to his game.
8. Jeremy Shockey (NO)
Shockey has been set back with injuries the past two to three years, but his talent and ability have not gone anywhere.
He can still run over pretty much any defensive back he wants to, and his “head-kill” attitude has not vanished either.
Shockey’s ability to get open and catch a football has never been questioned, and if anything, the injury time he used to workout might turn him into a better blocker. Playing with the Saints’ offense might be too up-beat for Shockey to roll with, so he might be substituting a lot with Miller.
Overall, though, Shockey is still a tough reliable player who just needs to stay on the field in order to produce for himself and his team.
9. Owen Daniels (HOU)
I had Daniels as high as No. 5, but then I came back down to Earth.
This guy’s talent is unbelievable, and he looks to be the next up-and-coming tight end.
As of right now, it is hard to rank him above players who have already shown the talent he displays, and then some. If Daniels wants to prove to the league that he is a top tight end, he will need to produce nicely this year.
He can run a route as good as any other tight end and displays great focus each play he is in. His blocking comes and goes, but now that Slaton is the starter, the running game might be more consistent this year.
He is a young talent with tons of potential that gives the Houston offense a nice piece, but now it’s time to use him to the fullest of that potential. This could be the year that it happens.
10. Zach Miller (OAK)
Miller is the true No. 1 target in Oakland.
Miller is a perfect fit for the Raider offense and has great size that many team look for. He has the capability to produce big numbers each week, but I would like to see it come more often from this guy.
He has great hands and a solid vision of the field around him. He can cradle in any ball thrown his way by simply using his body to move defenders (kind of like Crumpler in his prime).
He’s another young talent with tons of potential, but now is the time to expose that potential.
11. Anthony Fasano (MIA)
You could make the case that Fasano belongs in the top ten, and I wouldn’t argue.
He is a tough player with only one thing on his mind: Get the job done. He goes where he needs to play and executes whatever is asked of him. His receiving ability is not as good as his blocking, but it is still overall impressive.
He might be the long-term solution to that position Miami has been missing ever since Randy McMichael made a one-handed catch that impressed the entire universe.
12. Kevin Boss (NYG)
This is the man who sent Jeremy Shockey to New Orleans, so he has got to be worth something.
Boss can run after the catch better than any other tight end in the league, except for maybe Vernon Davis. He is a block-first tight end with the skills to catch and run.
His route running skills are still in question, because he usually runs drags, outs and slants. His deep game could also improve, but he’s not that type of player.
Boss could actually be Eli Manning’s No. 1 target this year.
13. Todd Heap (BAL)
Why is it that before every NFL season I am never sure if Todd Heap will be playing?
This guy has the talent and ability to be the best tight end in the league, but he is never on the field.
Heap can run almost any route on anyone trying to cover him, and he can climb over most defenders to snag a ball and can block better than anyone.
Plain and simple, when Heap is on the field it is just another problem for opposing defenses.
The past four years though, Heap hasn’t done much but produce once or twice a season then disappear into the roster.
14. Vernon Davis (SF)
This might be a breakout year for Davis.
His athletic talent is just too scary to think about. He can gallop like a race horse and can probably bench press a couple of his fellow lineman.
Davis has always been a solid blocker for Gore and the rushing game, but Singletary might be the guy to break Vernon out of his shell. Davis’ reliability has not been proven, but he showed signs of being on the verge of exploding onto the scene at the end of last year.
The San Francisco offense will surprise people, I believe, which I think Vernon Davis will be a big piece of.
15. Bo Scaife (TEN)
Although Crumpler is listed as the No. 1 tight end, Scaife got double the looks from Collins last year.
Scaife can run a vertical route very nicely and has good elusiveness for the size he brings. He can climb the ladder to compete in jump balls, but if he positions himself correctly, Sacife will win the battle every time.
He is a very precise route runner when it comes to his shorter routes, and uses his body to create an easy window for his quarterback to get the ball through. Having Crumpler line up with him definitely helps him get more looks.
He is a very reliable target for Collins in many situations and can quietly be an effective player for any offense.
16. Greg Olsen (CHI)
Olsen didn’t explode like I thought he would last season, but he didn’t disappoint either.
His speed and route running ability was just what I thought it would be, and his receiving didn’t surprise either. Olsen needs to become a more aware player on the field, but that will come with experience.
Desmond Clark’s presence can help Olsen learn the game and develop success quickly (along with Cutler), but if Chicago wants Olsen to blossom into a superstar player, Clark’s time will need to expire real soon.
Clark’s presence is helping Olsen, but if he stays there much longer, then it will hold Olsen back rather than push him forward.
17. John Carlson (SEA)
Carlson’s speed surprises many NFL defenses.
He is a 6’5″ monster with a hard working mindset and surprisingly soft hands. He reminds me of a young Heath Miller the way he attacks secondaries and takes hits over the middle.
Carlson has the ability to change directions quickly and fool defenders on where he is going on the field. He can also block, but that offensive line needs a lot more work to become successful.
Overall, Carlson still has a lot to learn about the game, but he is developing faster than any other young talent I’ve seen so far.
18. Ben Watson (NE)
Watson has done a good job of securing his job as Brady’s tight end in New England.
He has become a mature and reliable receiver for New England and has really filled his role well. Watson has the best acrobatic ability I’ve seen in a tight end since McMichael in his prime.
Watson’s route running is good, but not great, but his ability to find the open windows is a rare talent to find and his awareness improves each season.
If you add that with his athletic talent, you have a very solid and reliable player on your offense.
19. Martellus Bennett (DAL)
Bennett can start for numerous teams in the NFL today.
His height and athletic ability separate himself from many starters in the league. Bennett can use his body to get open, and he makes big plays every now and then.
However, he still has a lot of maturing to do if he wants to be a successful No. 1 tight end someday.
His talent has the potential to become great, but his football intelligence and maturity are two key pieces that are missing greatly from his game.
20. Tony Scheffler (DEN)
He reminds me of an underachieving Owen Daniels.
Scheffler’s numbers may be held back due to the playing time Daniel Graham holds, but Scheffler’s potential is still very high.
He can run simple routes and make tough catches that help keep offensive drives alive. His blocking is still questionable, and now that Cutler is gone, I am uncertain on how he will develop this year.
Scheffler’s game was inconsistent, to say the least, but the determination and ability he has can elevate his game to the next level in the future.
21. Brandon Pettigrew (DET)
I know people in Detroit didn’t like this pick, but I didn’t mind it.
Pettigrew is a big, athletic talent with a lot of potential to be great. He can jump, catch, run, and block, so what’s not to like about him?
Well, he is a rookie, so it will take some time for him to develop into a serious threat for opposing defenses. I still don’t know how intelligent Pettigrew is in the NFL, but then again, who honestly knows how rookies will play entering the league?
The talent is there, but the Lions organization might need to be patient with him before he becomes an immediate playmaker for this offense.
22. Visanthe Shiancoe (MIN)
Shiancoe can make big plays time from time, but he is no threat to opposing defenses as the key piece to the Minnesota offense.
Shiancoe will have his days where he just decides to catch everything thrown his way, then he has his days where he can’t separate himself from anyone on the field. Shiancoe’s success is mainly produced through Berrian, Taylor and Peterson’s play.
He is a solid tight end to have on any team, but don’t expect him to make the one play that will matter in the very end. He is one of those players who just has his days.
23. Dustin Keller (NYJ)
He has shown signs of becoming a reliable play maker for the Jets offense.
Keller’s speed is deceiving, and he has underrated receiving skills. Keller’s development on knowing what to do in certain situations has impressed me, but he won’t be playing with super-veteran Bret Favre. The young Keller will now be playing with the young Clemens (or Sanchez).
Keller’s talent can bring him into the spotlight one day, but he still has a lot to learn if he wants to produce nicely in his career.
24. Chase Coffman (CIN)
This is a rookie who has the talent and opportunity to secure a No. 1 role for Cincinnati.
Coffman has the size, hands, and toughness every team wants in their tight end. He has good speed to get down field for his size and is not afraid to put his shoulder down for two lousy yards.
I am very excited for the opportunity Coffman has to become successful in this league, and I can’t wait to see what he can bring to the Bengal offense.
25. Donald Lee (GB)
Lee is reliable leader that does whatever it takes to get the job done.
His receiving game is often overlooked, and his blocking is one of the best in the league. When I first saw Lee play, I thought this guy stood no shot at becoming the Packers’ No. 1 tight end long-term. As time went on, though, Lee started to impress me more and more.
He might not make the most flashy plays for Green Bay, but he does what he is asked to do in crucial situations.
That is a coach’s and quarterback’s best friend in close games—especially near December.
26. Alge Crumpler (TEN)
A proven tight end that blocks extremely well for one of the league’s best rushing attacks. He can receive as well as he blocks, too.
27. Desmond Clark (CHI)
A reliable player who can catch balls despite any defenders hanging on him. He is coming near the end of his career (sadly), but he can still produce for many offenses.
28. Daniel Graham (DEN)
I’ve always loved Graham, even in New England. Graham is good blocker with great hands and will go 100 percent every play he is in.
29. Marcedes Lewis (JAC)
Lewis is on the verge of being considered a bust. He must produce solidly this year (blocking or receiving) if he wants to secure a spot as the No. 1 tight end for Jacksonville in the future.
30. Brent Celek (PHI)
I think Celek could be a dark horse in the league this season. He is an overlooked player with great hands. You know how McNabb likes his tight ends, too.
31. Billy Miller (NO)
Miller is a decent receiver with terrible blocking skills. He is a solid tight end to have for the offense New Orleans has, but he can only be successful if put in the right system.
32. Alex Smith (NE)
Smith is a great blocker with an underrated receiving skill. He can find windows for quarterbacks in short-down situations.
33. Shawn Nelson (BUF)
A rookie who will get the opportunity to produce. Buffalo seems to like this kid, so if every piece on that offense falls into place, then Nelson should start to find some success.
34. Anthony Becht (ARI)
I’m still unsure if Pope will start over Becht. Pope has had plenty of time by now to develop as a reliable target. Signing Becht, I don’t think, is the answer, but it shows Arizona is ready to move on.
35. Chris Baker (NE)
Another veteran player that New England loves to attract. Baker is still a very productive player, and if used correctly, he can help do the little things that make the offense successful.
Published: July 8, 2009
Ranking the top receivers the league has to offer entering the 09′ season…
1. Randy Moss (New England)
He is arguably the most talented receiver to ever play the game. Moss can out run any receiver, split any coverage and catch any ball thrown his way. He will have an all-around better team playing with him this season rather than his ’08 year.
Brady is back and the entire organization is hungry for that Lombardi Trophy more than ever. New England is out to prove they are the best, and Moss is a huge part of that.
With more motivation to win and a better cast, I think New England’s offense might be as good if not better than when they went 18-0. If you think Fitz should be number one, that’s fine; but if Moss isn’t in your top two, I want to know what you’ve been watching this past decade.
2. Larry Fitzgerald (Arizona Cardinals)
This is a guy who could very well be on his way to becoming the best receiver to ever play. He is strong, big, fast, smart and the perfect teammate you would want in your locker room. He can jump over any defender because he positions himself perfectly to box out anybody trying to snag one on him.
He is an MVP-quality player and I still believe he should have won a Heisman Trophy. Any organization would be lucky to have a player like Fitzgerald.
3. Steve Smith (Carolina Panthers)
Smith is another receiver with MVP quality written all over him. His height comes as no concern because he has some of the best hops and speed in the league. He is not afraid to take a hit and has shown his toughness throughout his career.
He reminds me of a quicker and younger Hines Ward whose leadership is as big as his talent. A rare player to find in this league, and a play maker every time he steps onto the field.
4. Andre Johnson (Houstan Texans)
The only thing holding Andre Johnson back from becoming the best in the league is his injuries. Johnson has yet to play an entire NFL season on a consistent basis. When he is on the field however, he can out run and out catch anybody defending him.
He has the perfect speed and size to run almost any route and usually finishes plays real well. He is a tough receiver to bring down in the open field and never misses a stride when running. His potential is through the roof, but he needs to play more consistently to seriously hold any shot of becoming the best in this era.
5. Calvin Johnson (Detroit Lions)
I can’t believe this guy didn’t make the Pro Bowl! Calvin has every characteristic you would want in a receiver. He is tall, fast, a hard worker and has some of the best hands in the league. He separates himself from defenders extremely well when the ball is in the air and has the body to develop into a decent blocker.
His toughness mentally and physically is something he can improve on; but between the two years he has played in, Calvin has improved in that degree already. A threat to put up big numbers each week, and did so consistently last year.
6. Reggie Wayne (Indianapolis Colts)
One of the best route runners in the league and will only see more balls now that Harrison is gone for good. His speed, quickness and awareness makes him a constant threat on the field. He reminds me of a Torry Holt in his prime.
Wayne is another receiver who can catch almost anything thrown his way and has proven his liability throughout his career. Apart from how great of a pure football player Wayne is, the guy is a straight up athlete.
7. Anquan Boldin (Arizona Cardinals)
Boldin is opposite of what many people refer to receivers as prima donnas. He is a tough and explosive receiver with great hands and speed that hurts. His work ethic is one of the best in the league and he has brought a superstar level to his game consistently each year, despite on-going contract disputes.
Having Fitzgerald alongside only creates a better opportunity for getting him the football. Although I believe Fitz is a better receiver overall, Boldin was putting up better numbers than Fitzgerald was before he got hurt against New York. A number two in the desert, but number one talent overall.
8. Brandon Marshall (Denver Broncos)
Marshall said that he can catch any ball he wants to that is thrown his way; I don’t think he was kidding. This guy has freak-like talent that gives him the potential to become the league’s best one day. He has deceitful speed that allows him to out run most defenders.
His height and arm span gives quarterbacks an easy target in most situations (just like Moss, Fitzgerald and Ocho). I don’t question his mentality, I just don’t understand it. He seems to be a good kid for the most part; but whenever he is in the news, it’s for the wrong reasons.
A new place to call home might be what Marshall needs, but it’s not like staying in Denver will pull him down either.
9. T.J. Housmandzadeh (Seattle Seahawks)
T.J. has proven he can put up big numbers on a consistent basis. Some wonder whether or not TJ can take over as the number one in Seattle. Although Ochocinco was listed as Cincinnati’s number one, TJ has been the main target for that offense the past two seasons.
His ability has gone anywhere; he can still run just about any route and snag any ball. He knows where to go and how to get there in any situation you put him in. He will be playing with a smart and proven quarterback with play making capabilities.
10. Lee Evans (Buffalo Bills)
Evans has the talent to be a top receiver in this league. His speed to get vertical is very dangerous and his agility allows him to go to any part of the fields he wants. He hasn’t been high in the statistic categories recently, but I believe the addition of Owens will only enhance his ability to become a constant problem for opposing defenses.
I think Owens will allow Evans to play at his highest level of potential; but unfortunately, Trent Edwards has a lot to do with that too.
11. Chad Ochocinco (Cincinnati Bengals)
Chad has already proven he can be the best, but only when he is fully dedicated. Chad
“Johnson” used to run any route, catch any ball, jump over any defender and celebrate any touchdown. Johnson would talk trash to everyone and anyone. I remember he carried a list of cornerbacks of who would be guarding him each week and talk tons of shit.
You see, Johnson was at his best when his mindset was on football. It didn’t matter if he was talking trash, thinking of dances or playing with the media. Johnson’s mind was on being the better player on the field, which made himself and everyone else better as well.
The past two years, Ochocinco wasn’t focused on becoming a better player or team mate. Ochocinco was worried about starring in movies and trying to escape Cincinnati. His actions and attitude off-the-field reflected his play on-the-field. This year might be different however. Cincinnati got rid of T.J. in order to give Ochocinco more responsibility as their play maker.
Will he change? Apparently Ochocinco has been going crazy this off-season by working out. His attitude, work ethic and overall outlook has changed for the better so I do think Ochocinco will produce nicely this year.
This is a very talented and determined player entering the ’09 season hungry to taste success again; but more importantly, his mindset is back on football.
12. Roddy White (Atlanta Falcons)
When Roddy White first entered the NFL I thought he could be the next Marvin Harrison. After watching his style of play, I was obviously wrong; but potential talent might be the same. White is probably the most underrated route runner in the league. He can separate himself very nicely by only making one move.
He has some of the biggest hands compared to most receivers and concentrates on the ball extremely well when it’s in the air. White usually has a lot of receiving yards each year, but that’s mainly because of his ability to run after the catch. He is dangerous in the deep game, but not as consistent as the shorter routes.
Adding Gonzalez should only enhance his football knowledge and success.
13. Santana Moss (Washington Redskins)
This guy has big-play capability every time he runs down field. Moss is a very elusive receiver with great hands and a ton of heart. He can make defenders miss in the open-field and can sneak behind a secondary for the long ball. He is another receiver who despite being “altitude-challenged,” plays hard and consistent.
Moss has always been very productive and has rarely underachieved in any part of his career. A very dangerous, under-the-radar receiver who puts up big and productive numbers each year.
14. Dwayne Bowe (Kansas City Chiefs)
I’m not going to lie, Dwayne Bowe surprised me two years ago when he become a threat in the league. I’m not sure why though, mainly because he was a rookie. He has the height and build you would want any receiver to have; plus his speed, hands and leaping ability gives him a pretty nice arsenal to work with.
He is not afraid to make big plays when needed and has as much guts as he does dreads. His awareness on what to do in certain situations needs improvement and must show he can take over as the true number one target (now that Gonzo is gone).
15. Greg Jennings (Green Bay Packers)
Jennings is one of the most physical receivers in the league. He is a tough, fast receiver with the ability to bounce off tackles and hit the home run play. His hands are as good as they come and he has a nice receiver complimenting him in Driver.
Grant and the running game could help him out as well, but overall Jennings has the ability to take over as the go-to guy when the game is on the line. His football intelligence if often overlooked and is one of his most dangerous abilities in the game.
16. Wes Welker (New England Patriots)
Welker should pick up right where he left off. Despite Brady’s absence, Welker still produced solid numbers for New England last season. His speed is obviously his best quality, but Welker has come into his own as very reliable target.
He has the intelligence and ability to help carry any offense, let alone New England’s, far into a season. He can make the big play if needed, but does a better job of running underneath before going deep.
17. Roy Williams (Dallas Cowboys)
I’m not sure why people say this man is a bust. It is very hard for any player, let alone a receiver, to come to a new team midseason and dominate immediately. Williams has proven he has the talent and ability to produce nicely.
Now that he has been given time to work more closely with the offense, expect a much more educated Roy E. Williams this year. Witten still might be the true number one, but Williams should produce nicely either way. He is a long receiver with great speed and soft hands. His toughness comes and goes, but his big play capability has yet to disappear.
18. Terrell Owens (Buffalo Bills)
It is hard to rank T.O. this low, but his drops continue to tally. He still has the ability to bounce off most defenders and create big play opportunities. His toughness and desire have seemed to lack, but he always freshens up when he enters a new city. Why should this year be any different?
I don’t want to hear anything about his attitude in the clubhouse or his cause for drama. The only legitimate reason I see why T.O. won’t produce this year is because of Trent Edwards. If you think this guy’s talent is gone, you are insane.
He might even be a blessing in disguise in Buffalo. The organization and city is treating this man like a king. They gave him a key to the city, a welcoming ceremony at the airport and a laid back atmosphere to work under (never complained about him missing workouts).
You might think those are reasons T.O. is a “cancer,” but it might actually work in his favor. Owens plays well when he is happy; and when Owens plays well, the team around him plays well.
What makes Owens happy? Being the center of attention, an important player on the team, someone to look up to as a leader and being able to do whatever he wants to do. Buffalo is a place where T.O. can do all of those things which makes him more comfortable with the team he is playing for.
When Owens is happy and comfortable, he can help take a team to the playoffs. You want to talk about track records with this guy? Look at what this man has done with each team he has been on so far.
He has the record for most receptions in a football game while with San Francisco. He had one of his best performances with Philadelphia in the Super Bowl (despite a broken leg) and had the most touchdown catches in one season with Dallas (although he did hold most drops one year too).
Look at the track record on-the-field and not the one off-the-field; because now, he is in a place where none of that will matter.
19. Derrick Mason (Baltimore Ravens)
He is probably the most underrated receiver in the league today. Mason was on top of the league in receptions two years ago and helped guide a young Flacco deep into an NFL season.
He is fast, explosive and determined just as much as Ray Lewis. He is not afraid to brawl and has some of the best football knowledge in the league today. He is always in the post-season and that is no coincidence. Flacco’s game will only improve, and that will also elevate Mason’s game as well.
I would only be concerned with injuries when I hear Derrick Mason (mainly due to his age), but this is one of the best veteran leaders in the game.
20. Donald Driver (Green Bay Packers)
Driver is a more experienced Greg Jennings. The style of play those two show is almost exact. They can both bounce off of tackles, explode on the run, catch almost any ball and go deep at any point in time.
He is another veteran receiver you can trust in certain situations. One thing you can count on from Driver is that he will be one of the toughest and fearless players on the field each week, which is scary if you mix in his football ability. He is a great football player who uses his game to do his talking.
21. Marques Colston (New Orleans Saints)
Colston is one of the best receivers at climbing the ladder. He can snag a ball at its highest point while running in stride. His short routes tend to be a lot slower than his deeper routes, so it is very easy to read what Colston is doing.
When the ball gets to him though, he will grab it and never let go. He is always a threat to create a big play across the middle. he also does a great job of boxing defenders out with his size. I don’t think his thumb will bother him this year and I expect an overall solid year from Colston.
22. Santonio Holmes (Pittsburgh Steelers)
Holmes is on the verge of just exploding as a top receiver. His size limits him from out jumping one-on-one coverage, but his speed and hands make up for that. He can get anywhere he wants to go and has developed better hands every year.
His offseason workouts have been extremely good from what I’ve heard, so he might be on the brink of having his best season yet. He can make the big play when needed which is what it comes down to in the end.
23. Hines Ward (Pittsburgh Steelers)
What can’t this guy do? Out jump one-on-one coverage, that’s about it.
24. Antonio Bryant (Tampa Bay Buccaneers)
I have always been impressed with Bryant’s athletic ability. He is a big body receiver who never quite figured out how to stay productive. He has finally found his jig in Tampa Bay yesteryear and displayed many highlight-type catches.
He seems a lot stronger than he has been in the past and is running with a purpose to get somewhere. I like the new Antonio Bryant and I don’t believe he is a fluke. Winslow will help take pressure off of him as well.
25. DeSean Jackson (Philadelphia Eagles)
He is quickly turning into a playmaker. His intelligence needs vast improvement, but is a very confident and athletic talent with tons of potential. His route running skills are very nice which is scary because he is so young.
He, along with every Eagle receiver, is a deep threat almost every play. He can make defenses pay with one step and displayed pretty decent hands. His consistency and determination as a mature NFL player needs development; but other than that, the sky is the limit for this kid.
26. Jerricho Cotchery (New York Jets)
Cotchery has the talent and potential to become a reliable number one in his career. He has won the starting role in New York and with a new coach and system, his career might be secure if he can produce like he has the past few seasons.
Cotchery can jump with any defender, and slip by coverage to get open. He is a big target with great route running ability to go deep. He seems to be a hard-working player determined to become great. I like the future for Jerricho as a top receiver, just not the immediate future.
27. Lavernous Coles (Cincinnati Bengals)
Coles is another underrated receiver with a lot of quality. He is a reliable target for any offense he is a part of. Coles has been the number one his entire career, now playing with the talented Ochocinco might help elevate his game to a higher standard.
Most people see Coles going to the Bengals as the beginning of the end in his career, but I believe he will produce the same way he did back in his prime.
The Bengals have a great supporting cast around Coles; and if he can learn the playbook and adapt quickly, then he might be producing solid numbers on a consistent week-to-week basis.
28. Bernard Berrian (Minnesota Vikings)
Berrian is an explosive playmaker any way you want to look at it. He can run with any defender and exploded quickly after making the catch. Every time he touches the ball it seems he is running away, mainly because he is not a receiver who can run sit-down routes as well.
He is most dangerous when his legs are moving. His vertical game is one of the best in the league and could actually compete as one of the best given a decent quarterback and maturity.
29. Torry Holt (Jacksonville Jaguars)
It hurts to rank Torry Holt this low, but he is still a very reliable receiver. It is hard to see Holt in anything but a Rams uniform and I’m not sure how he will fit in with Jacksonville.
Garrard will ultimately determine Holt’s overall success at the end of the year, but he is still the same great route running, ball-snagging receiver he was five years ago.
He is easily one of the best receivers I have ever witnessed play this game; and if Jacksonville is his last stop, I hope he does well there. A solid, reliable talent who brings a great character and work ethic to his game.
30. Braylon Edwards (Cleveland Browns)
Braylon had a terrible season last year. He dropped every ball thrown his way and seemed out-of-sync the entire season. He has shown he has the capability to become a top receiver in the league; but if his attitude continues to be negative, then his game play will mirror that.
Braylon needs confidence and motivation to do well which I’m not sure he has. That shouldn’t take away from this kid’s talent and what he is capable of bringing each week.
31. Chris Chambers (San Diego Chargers)
Chambers is an under-the-radar receiver who hurts defenses every time he sees the field. Chambers runs sneaky routes that give quarterbacks a big, but hidden window to throw to. Chambers is probably the most aware receiver in the league and has the second best (behind Randy Moss) ability to make a catch on the sidelines.
He brings precision to his game and despite his 5’11” height, can make acrobatic catches that many receivers can’t make. Chambers can take over a game through the air; but with all of the talent on that offense, it is hard to get him the ball that many times in one game.
32. Vincent Jackson (San Diego Chargers)
Jackson always produces well when he is involved in a game. His height and speed keeps defenses guessing whether he will keep running or just stop and go inside.
Jackson is a great receiver in the deep passing game and has made a ton of big plays for that offense the past few years. He positions his body nicely to make the best play on the ball and usually wins.
Jackson has yet to show his reliability down the stretch of an NFL season though; but if Jackson can produce up to his full potential, then the San Diego offense should be in good shape the entire year.
33. Eddie Royal (Denver Broncos)
Royal is a great route runner with tons of speed and potential. He is not afraid to go across the middle of the field and look for the big play. His motor is always running and I’ve never seen him complain on the field. He is a good, hard-working individual with a humble but deadly approach to his game.
His feet skills are amazing and can burn any defender with one change in direction. I don’t see any reason why Royal should produce again this year. I don’t think Cutler made this kid good, Royal is just an athlete.
34. Issac Bruce (San Francisco 49ers)
Bruce and Hill might be an under-looked duo in the league this year. Bruce has the ability to keep chains moving on drives, especially on third down situations. His routes are precise and his hands are softer than toilet paper. He understands the game and is a good leader for the young receivers on that squad. He can put up numbers on a consistent basis and is the ‘safety net’ of the receiving core. Davis might develop into his own this year, which might take attention off of Bruce too. Bruce might have a quietly successful season; but if he does, then San Francisco should be a contender.
35. Mark Clayton (Baltimore Ravens)
Clayton really started to come into his own last year. He had struggled to develop his game when he first entered the league, but became a bigger target for Flacco as the season moved on.
He can break away from tackles while keeping his speed and direction. His ball handling skills has improved over the years and has finally figured out how to separate himself from defenders. Clayton and Mason could be two of the most reliable receivers next season, which is all Flacco needs to move this offense in the right direction.
36. Devin Hester (Chicago Bears)
If Devin Hester is going to develop into the receiver Chicago wants him to, this is the year. He has shown signs of becoming a solid receiver for this ball club. Chicago needs to show more confidence in his game if they want him to take over as a long-term target.
Hester can run away from anyone covering him and is not afraid to go up and grab a ball. He can take a hit without loosing much speed. I think he has the potential to reach Steve Smith status later in his career; but overall, he is a number two at best.
37. Miles Austin (Dallas Cowboys)
This should be a player on everybody’s sleeper list. Austin has some of the best hands I’ve seen from any up-and-coming receiver. He has the speed and quickness to run sharp and precise routes and a very tough mindset.
There is nothing to hate about Miles Austin other than he hasn’t played a lot. I believe he has taken Patrick Crayton’s role as the number two, but I think he has earned it. Another receiver who reminds me of Hines Ward, except can he block like him?
38. Percy Harvin (Minnesotga Vikings)
I still think Percy is the best receiver coming out of the draft. He is fast, explosive, smart, tough, and focused.
Adding Harvin’s athletic ability with players like Adrian Peterson, Chester Taylor, Bernard Berrian, and dare I say Brett Favre should help bring confidence to his game. All the talk is on Maclin being the top rookie receiver, but I like Harvin.
39. Steve Breaston (Arizona Cardinals)
Breaston proved he can take over as the number two receiver if Boldin wants to leave. He torched way too many defenders in the slot and could go up and grab a ball with most defenders.
If Breaston turns a corner, don’t bother chasing him because he is gone. The Arizona receiving core is eerily similar to the triple threat core Minnesota had with Moss, Carter, and Reed.
Breaston has the ability to be a number two for many organizations, but having him as the slot is perfect for his style of play. A vertical route runner with speed and hands makes Breaston a third threat for most defenses he faces.
40. Johnnie Lee Higgins (OAK)—Great speed and mindset can turn this hardworking kid into a go-to guy in the future.
41. Lance Moore (NO)—The numbers he produced last season shouldn’t surprise you. He can snag any ball in his range, the problem is his range is not that big.
42. Anthony Gonzalez (IND)—Great hands and route running skills are nice to have, but Peyton as your quarterback helps a lot too.
43. Greg Camarillo (MIA)—I’m actually going to pay attention to Camarillo this year. He surprised many last season with his game, but can he do it again?
44. Kevin Curtis (PHI)—If he can stay healthy on a consistent basis, I’d put him in the top 25. He is a big play threat when he is on the field. The problem, he can never stay on the field.
45. Joey Galloway (NE)—He has been a number one every team he has played for. His talent goes without saying, now adding him as the slot in New England almost seems unfair.
46. Tedd Ginn Jr (MIA)—Could have a breakout year, but Camarillo and Bess are breathing down his neck for the number one spot. If he can produce big plays more often, then his starting role should be fine.
47. Justin Gage (TEN)—The most under-rated route runner in the league and can separate himself from most defenders with his height. A breakout year from Gage is expected from me and having him as low as No. 47 is actually an insult.
48. Mushin Muhammad (CAR)—A reliable veteran for a team who is hungry for a ring. Anytime you add those things together you always get something good.
49. Kevin Walter (HOU)—A hard worker who really found his way into the offense last year. He can become a reliable number two, but must keep up with the up-beat tempo Houston’s offense has for an entire NFL season.
50. Antwaan Randle EL (WAS)—Another proven receiver with a ton of talent. He can throw, catch, and run. He seems like the perfect utility player for many offenses.
51-60
51. Donnie Avery (STL)
52. Rashied Davis (CHI)
53. Davone Bess (MIA)
54. Michael Jenkins (ATL)
55. Bryant Johnson (DET)
56. Brandon Jones (SF)
57. Darrius Heyward-Bey (OAK)
58. Patrick Crayton (DAL)
59. Jason Hill (SF)
60. Harry Douglas (ATL)
Published: June 8, 2009
Ranking the best running backs the league has to offer (there are about 39 “starter” quality running backs).
1) Adrian Peterson (MIN)
He has elevated his game to an MVP status in his third year. He is one of the best down-field runners and has an underrated receiving skills as well. He reads the holes well and even if it closes, he has the ability to create a positive play.
I only see two weaknesses for Peterson: He needs to limit his fumbles and accumulate more playing time. Nothing against Chester Taylor, but Peterson is a threat to score every time he touches the ball.
He has to prove he can consistently hold onto the football through an entire NFL season. Peterson had nine fumbles last year and if he wants to carry this offense and contend for an MVP award, he has to cut down on turnovers.
2) LaDainian Tomlinson (SD)
If he is not your No. 1, then there is no reason to rank him below the top three. I understand LT didn’t have a hot ’08 season, but that doesn’t mean you can just write him off. He already has Hall of Fame written all over him, and hasn’t even won a Super Bowl. He is a back that can run, catch, block and sometimes throw.
I believe a large reason why he struggled last year was because of his prior offseason. He seemed out of sync with working out and didn’t take a preseason snap.
Last year, I believe, was a gut check for LT. He has proven he can carry an offense into the playoffs, and the players around him can only enhance his confidence and play.
He is working very hard this offseason and is going to be playing with a chip on his shoulders. Norv can take playing time away from him early in the season; but ultimately, LT is the reliable playmaker for this offense.
If he struggles this year, then I would buy a lower ranking; but he is a proven superstar who seems angry, hungry and determined heading into this season rather than last.
3) Brian Westbrook (PHI)
This is probably the most electrifying player in the league, but needs to stay healthy. Westbrook needs to be a consistently healthy player to be considered a MVP talent on a serious level.
He has some of the best quickness, speed and playmaking abilities in the league. His receiving game is just as dangerous as his rushing, and having McNabb takes pressure off his shoulders. LeSean McCoy should be a nice backup for him, and possibly help keep Westbrook healthy for an entire season.
His knee surgery shouldn’t be a problem (according to Andy Reid), but it is something to consider.
In summary, the only thing keeping Westbrook from an MVP vote is his lack of playing consistently healthy. Adding Peters and McCoy should help (in someway) solve that problem.
4) Steven Jackson (STL)
This is the most athletic, man-beast of a running back you’ll find in the league. He is explosive, tough, fast, smart and a threat for big plays. Health has been the issue in recent years, but he seems to have overcome them pretty well. The Rams offensive line got better, so that should enhance Jackson’s rushing and receiving game.
He is a threat to score whenever he is on the field, but to become a top rusher, he needs to prove he can take leadership of the offense.
5) Clinton Portis (WAS)
His talent as one of the best is unquestioned. He proved his dominance in Denver, and has had a pretty solid career with Washington. He hits holes hard and can make guys miss with his power and speed. He has playmaking ability, but it comes and goes often. This is a streaky player that hasn’t proven his consistency since leaving Denver.
When Portis is on his hot streak, he can carry an offense on his shoulders. However, when Portis hits his cold streak, he struggles, which results in Jason Campbell having to run the offense (which a majority of the time fails).
Westbrook, Jackson, and Portis have MVP talent (which has been proven at some point in their careers), but have lacked consistency in recent years.
6) Chris Johnson (TEN)
A lot of attention is on Adrian Peterson as the best young running back (which may be true), but you have to consider Chris Johnson. This is one of the fastest players in the league and has unbelievable vision.
The holes he ran through last year were pretty big, but what he did to defenders in open space is just too scary to think about. I would like to see what his numbers would be like if he didn’t share carries with LenDale White, but Johnson has BIG playmaking ability written all over him. Unless Johnson gets hurt, I don’t see why he couldn’t finish with great rushing stats.
7) Michael Turner (ATL)
It is hard to sell Turner out of the top five (he did get an MVP vote last year). Turner is a bulky runner who has the power to run over a lot of defenders. His burst of speed to hit a hole and change of direction surprise most people; plus, Norwood compliments him nicely. The offensive line only got better in the offseason.
He is a threat for big play capability and is a reliable weapon in the red zone. With that said, both teams Turner has run for have had a great offensive line. I’m not saying is he not talented or he can’t put up solid numbers; but if the offensive line goes down, how effective can he be?
Something to think about, but Tuner should have a pretty consistent year.
8) Marion Barber (DAL)
I’m going to be honest; I get crunk every time I watch Marion run. This guy runs with determination and fire every time he touches the ball. He can straight plow through defenders and has a tough stiff arm. He can catch the ball as well as block.
There really isn’t anything negative to say about Marion, but he seems to lack maturity. However, his talent is good enough to succeed regardless of his maturity (especially with the weapons around him). Felix Jones may take some attempts away as well, but he should produce nicely for a majority of the season.
9) Brandon Jacobs (NYG)
Jacobs could be the most underrated back in the league. He is the biggest back with the nastiest attitude. If you don’t think so, ask LaRon Landry. The offensive line can open holes against most defenses, and Jacobs is going to be a huge piece to that offense. Jacobs can put up triple-digit rushing yards each week with multiple touchdowns.
Derrick Ward leaving might boost his carries and all-around stats at the end of the year, but he has proven he can take over the running game for this club. He tends to hit holes weak at some points during a game, so Ward’s departure might hurt his stamina (even though Ahmad Bradshaw is still there).
Jacobs is one of the best backs at keeping his feet moving at all times. Overall, Jacobs’ power and size make him a threat to opposing players every time he touches the ball.
10) Willie Parker (PIT)
Parker has been consistent for the most part of his career. He is running behind a below-average offensive line and still producing decently. His speed and ability to burst through any hole makes him a constant threat to defenses. His playmaking ability is one of the most under-rated and he fills his role nicely with that club.
Parker’s biggest weapon is his ability to turn the corner and hit break-away speed. That might be limited this year (due to the offensive line), because his big burst days seemed to be before Alan Faneca left. He is still a productive back with big-play ability, but that offensive line needs to improve if Parker wants to makes big plays on a consistent level.
11) DeAngelo Williams (CAR)
If Williams proved anything last year, he proved he can carry an offense on his shoulders. Granted the offensive line was solid and Stewart took pressure off of him; but when Williams was in, he was arguably the second best player on that offense.
He can break tackles and keep his uptempo pace at the same time. His quickness is overlooked, but his inside rushing ability comes and goes. Each year he has gotten better and I don’t believe we have seen the best this guy has to offer.
He can score multiple times in multiple different ways. He reminds me of a young LT; but he needs to prove he is one of the best this year, which I think he will.
12) Steve Slaton (HOU)
Slaton was a straight baller when he entered midseason as the starting running back. Slaton showed consistency and composure as the No. 1 back. He seemed very in sync with the offense; which is impressive, because it was his rookie year. He should only get better as time moves on and seems to play well with his surrounding cast.
Slaton can put up big numbers in both the rushing and receiving game. His ability to stay healthy for the time he was playing also impressed me. He finished last season like a Pro Bowl player; and if he continues to play where he left off last season, Slaton could be a top rusher in this league.
13) Frank Gore (SF)
This is another player who can change a game with one play. He is tough in between the tackles and has a nice burst of speed when changing directions. He is underrated in the receiving game and can block for Shaun Hill. Gore has proven he has superstar ability, and under Mike Singletary, his chances at succeeding are very high.
Gore is a tough, hard-nosed runner with a nice boost of speed. His leadership role on the offense needs to develop and his reads could improve. I am not sure if he is able to carry an offense for an entire NFL season, but his rushing attack is one of the best in the league.
14) Matt Forte (CHI)
He had a very productive rookie year behind an offensive line that only got better. Jay Cutler will take a ton of weight off of his back which should improve his consistency as a reliable back.
He has a big build with deceiving speed and pretty solid hands. He still has a lot to learn about the running game, but players on both sides of the ball will back him up nicely.
He is a tough runner and can break those mid-range runs for touchdowns. If his knowledge of the position can improve (which I think it will), then Forte could be a big piece to an offense with tons of potential.
15) Maurice Jones-Drew (JAC)
The only question I have for MJD is if he can carry an NFL team’s rushing attack by himself throughout the entire season. He is another tough, hard-nosed runner with a determination every time he touches the ball. His receiving game is good for the most part, and he can block with the best of the backs.
He is very small and reminds me of a cannonball or hedgehog when running. He bounces nicely off of tackles and keeps his momentum going forward. His veteran mentor Fred Taylor is long gone, so this is the year Jones-Drew needs to step it up. His performance on offense might ultimately determine how everyone else around him plays.
16) Ronnie Brown (MIA)
Ronnie Brown has the talent and attitude to be great, he is just way too risky. Brown is a hard runner with solid speed. The Wildcat formation might not be so successful this year, but that doesn’t mean Brown can’t produce. He is the best skill player on that offense and Ricky Williams gives him a nice backup to fall on.
His receiving game comes and goes, but for a large part he is a reliable target out of the backfield. Consistency seems to be Brown’s weakness (health-wise); but with the team around him and the talent he has, Brown needs to stay healthy to produce nicely for the fins this season.
17) Pierre Thomas (NO)
This is the most underrated back in the league. Thomas’ style reminds me of Kevin Faulk. He is a low-key runner with a great sense of finding holes and displays on-the-field knowledge. Thomas hits the holes quickly and efficiently.
Depending on what happens with Reggie Bush, Thomas may see limited rushing attempts; but that shouldn’t keep you from realizing how much talent this guy actually has.
His vision for holes and football awareness are hard to find in most NFL running backs today. He is a smart, hard-working player with a lot of skill. I would trust him to be a full-time starter for most NFL teams, including New Orleans.
18) Joseph Addai (IND)
Injuries were Addai’s setback last season. He still has a ton of skill with a winning mindset. He obviously has the talent to lead an offense on the ground, but can he do it himself? Rhodes was Addai’s fall back when he had his best season. He is young though, so his best season may have yet to come.
Will it be this year? It could be, since Indianapolis drafted the rookie back out of UConn (Donald Brown) to compliment him. Addai might not finish with top yards or touchdowns this year, but he will still be a productive back for a productive offense.
19) Willis McGahee (BAL)
McGahee’s work ethic sets him apart from most backs today. He went from a speed runner in college to a pretty powerful back in the league. It works for him though, because he has the tools of a quick but strong back. McGahee is going to split more time with Mc’Lain though, so his PT may not be so hot.
His productive value is still high and ultimately is the best all-around player on that offense. Joe Flacco’s play may also affect McGahee’s success (for the better). He is a talented and unique player that can carry an offense’s rushing attack for the most part.
20) Marshawn Lynch (BUF)
This is one of the most determined backs in the league. Every time he touches the ball, he puts his head down and hits the hole hard. He has the ability to hit the long run after breaking tackles, which makes him so dangerous. His speed is underrated and he can block as well.
His maturity is lacking, and I am worried that it won’t progress. This is a make or break year for Marshawn, at least in my eyes and long-term. I believe this year will answer a lot of questions for Buffalo’s offense, including the running game.
I think Marshawn easily has the talent and mindset to be Buffalo’s starter (long-term), but his lack of maturity will never elevate him to top rushing status on a serious level.
21) Darren McFadden (OAK)
For the few carries McFadden received last year, he was impressive. He is a great open-field runner with a ‘gym rat’ mindset to only do better. He has a nice compliment with Fargas and athletic talent all around him. Oakland’s offensive line is still pretty awful, so that could be a setback to McFadden’s game.
He is a hard-working kid with a ton of talent and a love for the game. His attitude and talent are rare to come by, but he needs a consistent offensive line to become more productive.
22) LenDale White (TEN)
He is the No. 2 running back for one of the league’s best rushing attacks. His power and agility combined make it tough for opponents to bring him down. The Tennessee offensive line is very good, which should attribute to White’s success this season. He is reliable red-zone target, but struggles with his receiving game.
When he is in open-field he is one of the toughest backs to catch and wrap up. I don’t expect the Titans rushing attack to struggle, so White should be a reliable and productive player for a majority of the season.
23) Jonathan Stewart (CAR)
Stewart is another hard-nosed runner with a lot of attitude to his game. He has a great feel for where he is on the field and what he needs to do in a given situation. All that said, that is pretty impressive for a rookie.
I don’t see any reason why Stewart and Williams should slow down this year; and, if anything, Stewart should see more red-zone carries and ultimately end up with more rushing touchdowns than he did last year. The Panthers’ rushing game does a good job of tiring out opponents, which Stewart plays a huge role in.
24) Ryan Grant (GB)
This is a player with a lot of talent, but no maturity. He is great at reading holes and does a good job running with power and speed. The problem for Grant last season was he always got wrapped up when he actually got to the hole. He needs to enhance his tackle-breaking skills and develop a bigger burst to hitting the holes.
Another problem he had last year was similar to LT’s. He sat out of training camp and preseason for a contract renewal. His mind was so focused on the contract it swayed away from the game itself. If he can get his mindset back on track, Grant could produce the numbers he is capable of. He needs more toughness mentally more than anything.
25) Thomas Jones (NYJ)
Jones is a hard-working, solid, reliable running back that can manage an offenses rushing attack. I think Jones has proven his capability of a solid No. 1. Leon Washington is just breathing down his neck for the starting role at this point.
Jones is a tough back with immense football knowledge; he can stay in and block which always helps young quarterbacks. The Jets might try to rely on Jones and Washington too much this year, but it’s not like they can’t handle the workload.
Jones is a hard runner with a great work ethic, but you can’t put too much on his plate at once (that’s where Washington fits in, I believe).
26) Leon Washington (NYJ)
Washington has turned into one of the league’s biggest playmakers. His speed, quickness, vision and ability to make guys miss separate his style from many others. If you don’t think he can start because of his size, I understand, but he has the potential of reaching that status in the future.
Jones rushing in front of him helps, but I would like to see how effective Washington can be with more carries this season. This is a great character player with a love and desire for the game. He takes nothing for granted and goes all out every play.
His open-field game is one of the best and has the ability to take any ball he touches a long distance. There are a lot more things Washington needs to improve if he wants to be back who can carry an offense, but his mindset and talent gives him a bright light for his future.
27) Larry Johnson (KC)
I believe Johnson is on the road to redemption. He has stated numerous times that he takes responsibilities for his actions and wants to get back to a top rusher in the league. Will he do it? Well the offensive line is not too shabby and having Cassel might bring confidence to this offense, but Larry can’t do it all by himself.
He was once a very talented runner and a huge playmaker. He can move the ball down the field and put up nice numbers. With a new mindset and approach to the game, Larry Johnson might have a successful year. He will need to maintain his new approach and play at a high level of consistency to re-gain his elite status.
28) Kevin Smith (DET)
He was a 1,000-yard rusher on a 0-16 team in his rookie year. He always kept an up-beat attitude and stayed focused and composed throughout the year. He hits holes quickly and efficiently, and can wiggle away from a lot of defenders. His field vision is solid and could be a huge asset for Detroit in the long run.
As of right now, Smith is just not as talented as the premier backs in the league. His future as the Lions go-to back is very realistic, but he will need to prove he can do what he did last year on a consistent basis.
29) Felix Jones (DAL)
Felix the cat should have an outstanding season. He looked very impressive before injuring himself. He is a sharp and precise runner with amazing speed and change in direction.
Running with Barber should only bring confidence to his game and he is probably even hungrier after sitting out a majority of last year. Felix is a change-of-pace back who can spark a big play if the offense is struggling. If Felix can stay healthy this year, he should pick up right where he left off.
30) Derrick Ward (TB)
Ward is one of the most explosive backs in the league. He has a great sense of where defenders are on the field and has great technique to his game. I wonder if Ward can run behind the Tampa offensive line as effectively as he did in New York.
This is a mysterious player with the ability to move an offensive rushing attack in the right direction. He has never been a featured back; so he will probably be splitting time, but his role as the starter is definitely possible.
31) Le’Ron McClain (BAL)
This guy can straight-up bulldoze people. He is a hard hitting back with the perfect ‘Baltimore’ attitude. He can play both halfback and fullback and is a reliable utility player for the Raven offense.
McClain’s speed lacks as well as his burst from the backfield. He takes a while to hit the hole; but if there aren’t any defenders when he gets to the hole, he is a tough runner to bring down in the open-field. You can not bring this guy down with only one defender, so if teams want to stop McClain, they better be able to pursuit.
32) Darren Sproles (SD)
Sproles is a deceiving player with big play capability. He has already proven himself as a reliable back in clutch situations.
I’m not sure if he is able to be an every down back in San Diego (or any other team), but he has enough football skill to be a dangerous player for any club. His burst of speed and change in direction is some of the best and he can vanish behind a big ole offensive line.
For a small body, he runs big. Sproles is not afraid to put his head down and take the big hit for the better of his team. Ultimately, Sproles’ quick attributes and surprising toughness makes him a threat to a majority of the NFL defenses.
33) Reggie Bush (NO)
I’m still not sold on Reggie being a reliable full-time back. I’m not saying he isn’t talented, but he needs to get a better grip on the NFL game. He is obviously not an inside rusher, which is something he can work on. His ability to make guys miss in open space is impressive, and his receiving game enhances his chance at success.
He needs a tougher attitude in order to survive the NFL season as an elite back, but his talent can carry him far into his career. He is one of the most athletic players in the NFL, and has playoff experience under his belt.
He has the ability to help an offense go far into the season, but I’m not sure is he has the toughness to take a serious leadership role for an organization.
34) Chester Taylor (MIN)
Taylor has been under-valued his entire career. He was obviously the best back in Baltimore (at the time) and got moved to Minnesota. Once in Minnesota, he established himself as an average starter.
Then the Vikings grab Adrian Peterson (I don’t blame them) and he becomes the second back again. The situation he is in might benefit his career if anything. Taylor doesn’t have enough talent or leadership to carry an offense’s rushing game deep into an NFL season.
He compliments Peterson very well, but Peterson deserves more than half of the carries in Minnesota. He is a reliable backup and has the ability to move an offense down the field when Peterson needs a break. A solid and reliable player to take pressure off of your star is hard to come by and that is what Taylor brings.
35) Sammy Morris (NE)
Morris is a very reliable runner who knows what to do in any given situation. He is a great role player, which is Belicheck’s ‘backbone’ to a Super Bowl team. Morris is a strong-willed runner with a motor that keeps on moving.
He understands his role on the team and executes it to perfection (like most New England players). Morris is a clutch third down back when it comes to awareness, focus, determination and the attitude to just get the job done.
36) Justin Fargas (OAK)
He has proven he can consistently produce numbers each week, but his talent and overall ability limits Oakland’s offense. He puts up good numbers each game, but in a game-time situation, Fargas is not a reliable player to handle the ball.
He is a strong runner who is not afraid to run into defenders. His desire is immeasurable; but again, his overall abilities can not compete with players like Peterson, Tomlinson or Portis.
37) Lawrence Maroney (NE)
Maroney was a back on the fence before he got hurt last year. He had success when New England went 18-1, but a lot of that had to do with opposing defenses dealing with Brady and Moss. Maroney’s ability as a reliable back comes and goes, but he is definitely the most athletic back in New England’s rotation.
Is he the best option to start for the Pats? With the addition of Fred Taylor and the proven ability of Faulk and Morris, I say no; he is not the best option as the starting back.
He has yet to break a big time play (in my mind) in his career, but that could be in large part due to Belicheck’s ‘humble pie’ (Patriot players do a good job of filling their role and nothing else).
38) Jamal Lewis (CLE)
He has proven he can lead an offensive rushing attack deep into an NFL season and has a Super Bowl ring to show for it. He has lost tons of speed and quickness since those days, but demonstrates good leadership ability and never gives up on a play.
He always keeps his feet moving when hit and can take on almost any player after he gets past the backers. His career is coming to a close (sadly), but he can still produce solidly for two or three more seasons.
39) Cedric Benson (CIN)
I think Benson will play better this year, but not consistently. Palmer and the passing game might take some pressure off of Benson, but he has to prove he can carry the rushing game for an NFL club.
He said he never wanted to compare to Ricky, so after his rookie miscues, I expect a determined and hard-working runner in the upcoming season. Don’t let his numbers take away how good Benson can be in the future. He was given a second opportunity, now it is up to him to make it work.
40) Chris Wells (ARI)
Wells might surprise people this year. The Arizona rushing game was ranked bottom-to-last in ‘08, so it’s hard to get much worse. The passing attack will remain as productive as it was last year, so there shouldn’t be too much attention on Beanie.
He is a big back with a great burst of speed. He can make defenders miss just by running at a different angle. Hightower might get the start over Beanie, but overall, I think Wells will become the future starter for this Cardinal club.
41-50
41) Tim Hightower (ARI)
He is a red zone threat with a hard-charging attitude. He brings confidence and ability to the rushing game, but his consistency needs to be proven.
42) Jerious Norwood (ATL)
His speed surprises many defenders, but also has the power to break tackles. He is reliable in the receiving game as well.
43) Donald Brown (IND)
Brown should compliment Addai nicely. If both Addai and Brown can stay healthy for the season, they could both benefit each other and help lead the Indy offense in the right direction.
44) Ricky Williams (MIA)
Williams has the ability to be a top-10 rusher in this league. Maybe the cannabis slowed down his overall desire for the game, but he is still one of the most talented backs I have ever witnessed.
45) Ahmad Bradshaw (NYG)
This is another explosive back in the Giants’ locker room. He brings the speed that Jacobs lacks, but keeps that tough mindset that the Giants organization likes.
46) Ray Rice (BAL)
His carries may be limited since McClain solidified his number two spot. McGahee and McClain haven’t played a whole season, so Rice will get his carries. He can fit into tight holes and make the little plays that keep a drive alive.
47) Ernest Graham (TB)
He has proven he can put points onto the board, but he struggled to find a consistent rhythm last year. Ward should help take pressure off of Graham.
48) Knowshon Moreno (DEN)
Moreno should start for Denver and see plenty of carries. He should be a reliable receiving target and could break a few big plays. He still has a lot to learn, but his talent could elevate him when the year is over. I think his stability should be questioned and his knowledge of the offense will develop throught the season.
49) Fred Taylor (NE)
Taylor is just another reliable veteran for Bill Belichick’s system. He is a proven player who is hungry for a Super Bowl ring. He has leadership qualities and could be the starter for New England at some points in the season.
50) Mwelde Moore (PIT)
This will be an interesting year for Mwelde. He had an impressive year, but a returning Mendenhall might take some opportunities away. Apparently Mendenhall is shaping to be Pittburgh’s future (Parker entering his last season in contract), so Moore might not have such a productive year.
However, he proved he can fit nicely with Pittsburgh and can play when given the chance.